Our broker uses one freight class for everything. Is that costing us?
Is one freight class on every LTL shipment costing us money?
A plant controller at a hypothetical manufacturer is reviewing freight spend. The company ships two kinds of products by LTL: dense steel brackets and bulky molded foam inserts. The broker that books all the company's LTL puts the same class on every BOL. Nobody remembers who chose that class or why. Some months, a handful of invoices arrive with reclass corrections. Other months, nothing. The controller wants to know whether the single class is a good deal the broker negotiated or a shortcut that is quietly costing money.
One freight class on every LTL shipment usually costs money, either through overpaying on dense freight rated too high or through reclass charges on light freight rated too low, unless the class comes from a written FAK agreement with the carrier that covers everything the company ships. The only way to know is to compare the class billed with the class each shipment should carry, using real weights and dimensions.
LTL pricing depends on weight, distance and freight class. Lower classes generally cost less per hundred pounds. Because the class is declared by the shipper or its broker, and checked by the carrier, a wrong class shows up in one of two ways. Too high, and the company pays more than it needs to on every shipment, with no correction ever coming. Too low, and the carrier may inspect the freight, reclassify it and bill the difference plus a fee.
What "one class for everything" usually means
When a broker uses one class for every shipment, it is usually one of three things:
- A freight-all-kinds (FAK) agreement. The carrier has agreed in writing to rate a range of classes at a single class for this shipper or for the broker's freight. This can be a legitimate pricing tool.
- A default the broker types in. The broker's quoting tool or the person booking uses the same class because nobody gave them product data. This is a shortcut, not a deal.
- A default from the shipper's own BOL. The company's shipping dock prints the same class on every BOL, and the broker copies it. The broker is repeating the company's own error.
Each case needs a different fix, so the first question to ask the broker is which one it is.
Why density matters more now
The National Motor Freight Traffic Association (NMFTA) publishes the National Motor Freight Classification (NMFC), the standard most LTL carriers use for freight class. Its 2025 changes under Docket 2025-1 took effect on July 19, 2025. NMFTA says that because density plays a larger role, accurate measurements are essential, and it points shippers to its ClassIT+ service as the official source for item changes and density scales.
For shippers, that means a class chosen years ago may no longer match the freight. A product that was classed by its description may now be classed by density. A single class that was close enough before can now be further off. For the mechanics of density-based class, see freight class and NMFC density.
Want a second look at your bills?
Let's review a few LTL bills and the classes on them. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers.
Book a demo →How do you check whether one freight class is costing you money?
Pull a sample of recent LTL bills, work out the class each shipment should have and compare it with the class billed and any corrections. The test takes a few hours and gives a clear answer.
Step 1: Pull a sample
Take 20 to 30 LTL shipments from the last three months. Include different products, pallet counts and lanes. For each one, collect the BOL, the carrier invoice, any reclass or reweigh corrections and the order with the products shipped.
Step 2: Record what actually shipped
For each shipment, write down the number of handling units, the weight of each unit and its dimensions after wrapping. If the dock does not record dims, measure a few typical pallets of each product now. Note mixed pallets, where several products share one pallet.
Step 3: Work out density
Density is weight divided by volume. For a pallet, multiply length, width and height in inches and divide by 1,728 to get cubic feet. Then divide the weight in pounds by the cubic feet to get pounds per cubic foot. A 48 by 40 by 50 inch pallet is 96,000 cubic inches, or about 55.6 cubic feet. At 500 pounds, its density is about 9 pounds per cubic foot. At 1,500 pounds, it is about 27.
Step 4: Find the class each product should have
Look up each product's NMFC item and the class it assigns, using the density from step 3 where the item is density-based. NMFTA's ClassIT+ is the official source. If the company does not have access, ask the carriers it books most often to confirm the class for its main products in writing. Some items are classed by handling or liability considerations rather than density alone, so do not assume density is the whole answer.
Step 5: Compare with what was billed
Put the class billed next to the class each shipment should carry. Mark each shipment as matching, billed higher or billed lower. For shipments billed lower, check whether the carrier issued a reclass. For shipments billed higher, note that no carrier will ever correct those in the company's favor.
Step 6: Price the difference
For a few shipments billed higher, ask the broker or an approved carrier to quote the same shipment at the correct class. The gap is what the company overpaid. For shipments billed lower, add up the reclass corrections and fees. Both numbers together are the cost of the single class.
A hypothetical audit worksheet
| Shipment | Product | Density (lb/cu ft) | Class that fits the freight | Class billed | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steel brackets | 27 | Lower than billed | One class for all | Overpaid, no correction |
| 2 | Foam inserts | 3 | Higher than billed | One class for all | Reclassed, extra charge |
| 3 | Mixed pallet | 11 | Close to billed | One class for all | No change |
| 4 | Steel brackets | 25 | Lower than billed | One class for all | Overpaid, no correction |
| 5 | Foam inserts | 4 | Higher than billed | One class for all | Not reclassed this time |
The worksheet is hypothetical. It shows the pattern that a single class often creates when a company ships both dense and light freight: the dense products subsidize the light ones on some loads, and the light ones trigger corrections on others.
What the result usually shows
If most shipments match, the single class may be fine or may come from a well-built FAK. If dense products are consistently billed higher, the company is paying too much on its heaviest freight. If light products are often reclassed, the corrections are the visible cost and the overpayment on dense freight is the hidden one.
What is an FAK agreement, and when is a single class legitimate?
An FAK agreement is a written pricing arrangement in which a carrier agrees to rate a range of classes as one class for a shipper or a broker's freight, and it is legitimate when the company can see the terms and the range covers its freight. Without the written terms, "we use one class" is just a habit.
How FAK works
Under an FAK, the carrier still knows what the freight is. The BOL still describes the commodity, the weight and the piece count. The agreement says that freight within a stated range of classes will be rated at one class. A shipper with many products in different classes can get simpler, more predictable pricing that way.
The details matter. An FAK may cover only some classes, only some lanes or only some commodities. Freight outside the range is rated at its actual class. The terms may also say what happens if the carrier inspects the freight and finds it outside the range. Each carrier's agreement is different, so read the actual terms rather than relying on a summary.
Whose FAK is it?
When a broker uses one class, ask whose agreement it is. If the broker holds an FAK with certain carriers, the class may apply only on those carriers and only while the company books through that broker. If the company later books some lanes directly, it may lose that pricing on those lanes. If the company holds the FAK itself, it applies on that carrier whoever books. Knowing who holds the agreement matters when deciding how to split freight between a broker and direct carriers. The article on keeping a broker as an option while booking some freight directly covers that transition.
When a single class is fine
- The company has seen the written FAK terms, and they cover the classes it ships.
- The BOL still describes each product accurately.
- Invoices show few or no reclass corrections.
- A sample audit shows dense freight is not consistently rated above its real class, or the overall price still beats rating each product at its own class.
When a single class is a problem
- Nobody can produce written terms.
- The class appears on the BOL but the commodity description is vague.
- Reclass corrections arrive regularly on the same products.
- Dense products are rated well above their real class and no FAK explains it.
One class: agreement or shortcut?
| Question | Written FAK | Broker default | Shipper's own BOL default |
|---|---|---|---|
| Is there a written document? | Yes, with the carrier | No | No |
| Who chose the class? | Negotiated with the carrier | The broker or its tool | The shipping dock or an old setup |
| Does the BOL describe the product? | It should | Often vague | Often vague |
| What happens on inspection? | Depends on the agreement terms | Reclass at the real class | Reclass at the real class |
| Can the company see the terms? | It should ask to | Nothing to see | Nothing to see |
| First fix | Read the terms and check the range | Give the broker product data | Fix the product master and the BOL |
What mistakes make a blanket freight class expensive?
The expensive mistakes are not asking where the class came from, paying reclass bills without checking them and leaving the product data wrong after the conversation with the broker. Each one has a direct fix.
Mistake 1: Never asking the broker where the class came from
The simplest question is often never asked. "Is this class from an FAK agreement, and can we see the terms?" If the answer is vague, the class is probably a default. Ask in writing so the answer is on record.
Mistake 2: Assuming the broker has product data
Many brokers price LTL from what the shipper gives them. If the company sends only a pallet count and a total weight, the broker has nothing to class from and uses a default. The fix is to give the broker, and every carrier, the same product data: commodity description, class per product, dims and weight per unit.
Mistake 3: Paying reclass corrections without evidence
A reclass correction should come with the carrier's inspection details. Ask for the inspection or weight certificate before paying. Compare the carrier's numbers with the BOL and the dock's own photos. The guide on stopping LTL reweigh and reclass charges covers how to dispute them.
Mistake 4: Only watching corrections, not overpayment
Corrections are visible on the invoice. Overpayment on dense freight rated too high is invisible, because no carrier sends a refund. Teams that only track reclass bills miss half the cost.
Mistake 5: Quoting at one class and shipping at another
If the quote uses one class and the BOL uses another, the invoice will not match the quote. The article on what happens when the LTL quote was right until the freight class changed shows how that gap appears.
Mistake 6: Leaving mixed pallets to guesswork
When several products share one pallet, the class should follow the rule the carrier applies to mixed shipments, which often depends on how the products are described and packed. Write down how mixed pallets are handled and apply it the same way every time.
Questions to ask the broker
- Is the single class from a written FAK agreement? With which carriers?
- Can we see the terms, including the class range and lanes covered?
- What happens when a carrier inspects and finds the freight outside the range?
- What product data do you need from us to rate each product at its own class?
- Can you quote a sample of our recent shipments at their actual classes for comparison?
- How many reclass corrections did our freight receive in the last six months?
Which checklist fixes freight class on every LTL shipment?
Freight class stays correct when the product data is right, the BOL is built from it and every invoice correction is checked. This checklist works whether the company books through a broker, directly with carriers or both.
| Item | What good looks like | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Product master | Each product has a commodity description, NMFC item and class | Logistics with product engineering |
| Unit dims and weight | Measured after packaging, per handling unit | Shipping dock |
| Density check | Density recorded for density-based items | Logistics |
| Mixed pallet rule | Written rule for pallets with several products | Logistics |
| FAK terms | Written terms on file, with class range and carriers | Logistics, purchasing |
| Quote data | Every quote uses the same class and dims as the BOL | Whoever books |
| BOL | Built from the order and product data, not typed by hand | Shipping and logistics |
| Dock photos | Each LTL pallet photographed with its label | Shipping dock |
| Class changes | Any change to class on the BOL goes to the load owner | Logistics |
| Invoice check | Each reclass or reweigh line compared with booking and documents | Logistics, finance |
| Evidence before payment | Inspection or weight certificate requested before paying a correction | Finance |
| Quarterly review | Sample of bills audited for class billed versus class that fits | Logistics |
How to fix the product master
Start with the products that ship most often by LTL. For each, record the commodity description, the NMFC item and the class, plus the packaged dims and weight per unit. Confirm the class with the official source or with a carrier in writing. Then make sure every BOL pulls from that record. A correct class that lives only in a spreadsheet on one person's computer does not help the dock on a busy afternoon.
How to check invoices going forward
Every carrier invoice with a reclass or reweigh line should be compared with the booking, the BOL and the dock photos before payment. If the correction is supported, pay it and fix the product data so it does not happen again. If it is not, dispute it in writing. The guide on checking a freight invoice against the agreed carrier quote covers the steps.
When to review again
Review the class sample every quarter, and any time packaging changes, a new product starts shipping by LTL or the NMFC publishes changes to items the company ships.
How does Wilson, by Cartage, handle freight class on LTL shipments?
Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes and books LTL with the class from the company's own product and order data, keeps the quote and the BOL consistent, routes any class change to the load owner and audits every reweigh and reclass line before a carrier is paid. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward.
cartage.ai describes Wilson as a free logistics department: what big shippers build over years, Wilson does from day one. For freight class, its four parts work like this.
The labor
The labor is the quoting, booking and paperwork. Wilson requests quotes from the company's approved carriers and brokers, compares them on total cost and negotiates toward the company's rate targets within approval limits. It books with written acceptance and a rate confirmation and generates the BOL, packing slip and pallet labels from the order, so the class quoted is the class shipped. If an order is missing a detail Wilson needs, it does not book it. It holds the order, asks for the detail, tells the team and never invents a value. The class itself comes from the company's product data; how that data reaches Wilson depends on the setup.
The data
The data keeps the class consistent. Wilson keeps every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact on record as it works, connected to the company's ERP. Every message, confirmation and change is kept in the shipment's change history. BOL changes to address, freight class, carrier or price are routed to the load owner, so a class edited at the dock does not slip through unnoticed. Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP.
Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope.
Wilson does not keep a permanent class scorecard by default, but it can produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs, which helps with the quarterly review.
The network
The network means the shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's for better freight rates on every lane. The network includes carriers and brokers, so a company that wants to keep its broker as an option can rank it on the lanes where it makes sense alongside direct carriers. The company still approves who hauls its freight.
The payments
The payments are where class errors get caught. Wilson audits each carrier invoice against the rate confirmation and POD, and checks reweigh and reclass lines against the booking and documents. An invoice over the rate or outside the rules is held for a person, and Wilson asks the carrier why before paying. Invoices that pass are paid from the Wilson Wallet.
Control and start
Control starts with assisted execution. The company sets approval limits, and routine actions run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.
Pricing
Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract.
FAQs
Can Wilson check the freight class on our LTL shipments?
Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, quotes and builds the BOL with the class from the company's own product and order data, so the quote and the BOL match. Any change to freight class on the BOL is routed to the load owner. Wilson audits reweigh and reclass lines on each invoice against the booking and documents and holds anything outside the rules for a person.
Is one freight class on every LTL shipment always wrong?
No. A written FAK agreement with the carrier can rate a range of classes at one class. It becomes a problem when there is no written agreement, when the range does not cover the company's freight or when reclass corrections keep arriving.
What does FAK mean in LTL freight?
FAK stands for freight all kinds. It is a pricing arrangement in which a carrier agrees to rate a range of classes at one class for a shipper or broker. The terms, including the class range and lanes covered, should be in writing.
How do I know if we are overpaying because of the class?
Compare the class billed with the class each shipment should carry, using real weights and dimensions. Then ask for quotes on a few dense shipments at their correct class. The gap is the overpayment.
Why do reclass charges come only on some shipments?
Carriers do not inspect every shipment. A light product rated too low may pass several times and then get reclassed. That is why the absence of corrections on one month's bills does not prove the class is right.
Did the 2025 NMFC changes affect freight class?
NMFTA's changes under Docket 2025-1 took effect on July 19, 2025. NMFTA says density plays a larger role and accurate measurements are essential. Check your main products against the current classification.
Can Wilson work with our broker and our own carriers?
Yes, if the company approves them. The network includes carriers and brokers, and booking uses a ranked list per lane, so the company decides where its broker and its direct carriers rank.
What should we send a broker so it can class our freight correctly?
Send the commodity description, the class per product, the packaged dimensions and the weight per handling unit. Agree on how mixed pallets are handled.
Should we pay a reclass correction right away?
Not before checking it. Ask for the inspection or weight certificate and compare it with the BOL and dock photos. Pay supported corrections and fix the product data; dispute the rest in writing.
Sources
- Cartage, Wilson product FAQ and product scope, October 2026: https://cartage.ai
- NMFTA, "NMFTA Implements Historic NMFC Changes; Launches ClassIT+ to Support Industry in Adapting to New Classification Standards": https://nmfta.org/news/nmfta-implements-historic-nmfc-changes-launches-classit-to-support-industry-in-adapting-to-new-classification-standards/
- NMFTA, 2025 NMFC changes overview and FAQ: https://info.nmfta.org/2025-nmfc-changes
Let's review a few LTL bills and the classes on them. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
