How should we review our carriers at year end?
How should you review your carriers at year end?
It is the second week of December at a building products manufacturer. The logistics manager has a meeting with the operations director in January to agree on carriers for next year. What she has today is a folder of carrier invoices, three years of email threads, a spreadsheet with rates that was last updated in spring and strong opinions from two coordinators. One carrier "always" misses pickups. Another is "the only one who answers the phone". Nobody can say how many loads each carrier actually moved on each lane, or what they cost after accessorials.
Review carriers at year end in five steps: pull a year of load records, measure service and paid cost for each carrier by lane and mode, check the numbers against your own causes, talk with each important carrier about what you found and what next year looks like, then re-rank the approved carriers on every lane. The goal is not a grade. It is a better booking decision on every load next year.
A good review answers three questions. Which carriers should get first look on each lane? Which carriers need a conversation about a specific problem? Which carriers are on the approved list but no longer earn a place there? Everything in the review should feed one of those three answers.
Why year end is the right moment
Year end lines up several decisions. Contract rates and lane targets are often reset for the new year. Some carriers announce rate changes for the coming year, and the shipper needs its own numbers before it responds. Budgets for freight spend are set. And the team has a full year of seasons in the records, including peak periods, holidays and weather, so the picture is more complete than a quarterly look.
It is also the right moment because December and January are quieter for many manufacturers. A review squeezed into a busy week becomes a list of complaints. A review with time for data and conversations becomes a plan.
What the review is not
A year-end review is not a freight bid. A bid asks carriers to price your lanes from scratch, and it is a larger project with its own steps; see how to run a freight bid for your lanes if that is what the year calls for. The review can tell you whether a bid is needed, and on which lanes, but it starts from the carriers you already use.
It is also not a permanent scorecard. A scorecard updates every week or month. A year-end review is a decision meeting that happens once, with a fixed data set and a clear output. Many teams do both, and what carrier scorecard software should measure covers the ongoing side.
Let's review your carriers with a year of loads on the table. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers.
Book a demo →What are the steps of a year-end carrier review?
Pull the records, measure by lane, check your own causes, talk to the carriers and re-rank. Each step has a clear output, and the steps run in order because each one depends on the one before.
Step 1: Pull a year of load records
Gather every load from the year with these fields, as far as your records allow:
- Carrier, mode (LTL, truckload, parcel, ocean, drayage) and equipment.
- Origin, destination and lane.
- Tender date, whether the carrier accepted and how fast.
- Agreed pickup and delivery dates, and actual pickup and delivery times.
- Quoted rate, rate on the rate confirmation and the amount invoiced and paid.
- Accessorials, reweigh or reclass corrections and invoice disputes.
- Claims for damage or loss, and their outcome.
- POD received date.
The records often live in four places: the ERP, carrier invoices in accounts payable, email threads and carrier websites. Expect the first pull to have gaps. Note them, because the gaps are themselves a finding: if nobody can say when a load was delivered, nobody could have told the customer either.
Step 2: Measure each carrier by lane and mode
Group the loads by carrier, lane and mode. A lane can be a city pair, a state pair or a region pair, as long as it is the same definition for every carrier. For each group, measure the handful of things that matter most to your customers and your budget. The table later in this article lists them.
Set a minimum sample size. A carrier with three loads on a lane has an anecdote, not a record. Many teams mark any group under ten loads as "not enough data" and look at those carriers more broadly by region or mode.
Step 3: Check your own causes
Before judging a carrier, check which misses came from the shipper side. A late pickup may have been a late order, freight not ready at the dock or a pickup time the carrier never agreed to. Detention may have been caused by a slow loading dock. A reweigh may have been correct because the order weight was wrong. Mark these loads so they do not count against the carrier, and list them separately: they are your own to-do list for next year.
This step changes conversations. A carrier shown a list of late pickups that includes eight loads the plant was not ready for will stop listening. A carrier shown a clean list will usually engage.
Step 4: Talk to each important carrier
Schedule a short call or meeting with every carrier that moved meaningful volume. Send them the data first, so they can check it. The agenda is covered in the checklist section below. Keep the tone practical: you want next year's service, capacity and rates, not an apology for last year.
For carriers with small volume, an email with the numbers and two questions may be enough: do you want more freight on these lanes, and at what rate?
Step 5: Re-rank the lanes and write it down
For each lane, set the order in which approved carriers get first look, the rate target and any rules, such as "carrier B only for loads under 10 pallets" or "carrier C as backup on Fridays". Mark carriers to trial on specific lanes and carriers to retire from the approved list. Then write down the date of the next review.
The ranking is the real output. If it lives only in the meeting notes, the coordinators will book next year the same way they booked this year.
Which numbers should a carrier review use?
Use a short list of numbers that connect to real costs and customer promises: tender acceptance, on-time pickup, on-time delivery, paid cost against agreed cost, invoice accuracy, claims and responsiveness. More numbers do not make a better review. They make a longer meeting.
Tender acceptance
How often did the carrier accept the loads it was offered on the lane, and how fast did it answer? A low acceptance rate on a lane where the carrier is ranked first means the team keeps starting from the second carrier anyway. Fast answers matter for same-day and next-day freight, where a slow no costs as much as a no.
On-time pickup and delivery
Measure against the agreed date and time, not against the date the carrier later proposed. If a carrier changed the pickup to the next day and the team accepted, record that as a change, then decide whether it counts. Be consistent across carriers. For delivery, use the POD time or the receiver's record when available, because carrier status updates can lag.
Paid cost against agreed cost
For each carrier and lane, compare the amount paid with the rate on the rate confirmation. The difference shows accessorials, reweighs, reclasses and billing errors. A carrier with a lower base rate and frequent added charges may cost more than one with a higher rate and clean invoices.
Invoice accuracy
Count how many invoices matched the rate confirmation and POD on the first pass, and how many needed a dispute or correction. Invoice problems create work in accounts payable and delay payments, which carriers also notice. If invoices are checked before payment, this number comes straight from the audit results; see freight invoice controls before payment for how that check works.
Claims
Count damage and loss claims per carrier and lane, the amounts and how long each took to settle. One large claim can say more than many small delays. Under federal law, 49 U.S.C. 14706 sets minimum periods for freight claims against motor carriers: carriers may not require less than nine months to file a claim or less than two years to bring a lawsuit after a written denial. Check that open claims from the year are still inside those windows before the review closes them out.
Responsiveness and documents
How easy was the carrier to reach when something went wrong? How long did it take to send PODs after delivery? These are harder to measure by hand, but they show up in the email record. A carrier whose dispatch answers on the first call saves the team hours every week.
What not to measure
Avoid numbers you cannot collect the same way for every carrier. A half-measured metric invites arguments. Also avoid ranking carriers on one blended score across all lanes. The team books lane by lane, so the review should decide lane by lane.
What goes wrong in year-end carrier reviews?
Most reviews fail because they rely on memory, mix lanes together, ignore the shipper's own role in misses or end without a written ranking. Each mistake has a simple fix.
Mistake 1: Judging on the loudest stories
Every team remembers the load that went wrong in front of the biggest customer. Memory is a poor sample. Start with the records, then use the stories to explain the numbers, not to replace them.
Mistake 2: One average per carrier
A carrier's overall on-time rate blends lanes where it is strong with lanes where it should not be booked. Decide by lane and mode.
Mistake 3: Comparing quoted rates instead of paid cost
The quote is a promise. The invoice is the cost. Reviews that compare quoted rates reward carriers that quote low and bill high.
Mistake 4: Blaming carriers for shipper-side misses
Freight not ready, wrong weights, missing appointments and slow docks are common causes of carrier misses. Remove them from the carrier's record and fix them inside the company.
Mistake 5: Keeping every carrier on the list
Approved lists grow over time. Carriers added for one emergency stay on for years, their contacts go stale and their rates expire. A carrier that has not moved a load in a year should either be re-engaged with a clear lane or retired from the list, so the team does not tender to it by habit.
Mistake 6: Changing every lane at once
Moving all lanes to new carriers on January 2 adds risk at the moment the team has the least history with the new choices. Change the lanes where the data is clear, and trial new carriers on a few lanes first. Trialing a new carrier before critical loads covers how to limit a new carrier to specific lanes while it proves itself.
Mistake 7: Not telling the carriers
Carriers plan capacity around expected freight. A carrier that moves from second to first on a lane should know, and so should a carrier that moves down. A carrier that hears nothing will keep quoting the same way.
Mistake 8: No date for the next look
A once-a-year review lets problems run for months. Set a short mid-year check on the lanes that changed, so a bad ranking does not wait until next December.
What checklist and agenda should the review follow?
Use a data checklist before the review, a meeting agenda with each carrier and a decision table for each lane. The tables below are generic. Adjust them to your modes and lanes.
Data checklist
| Number | How to measure | Where the data comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Loads by carrier, lane and mode | Count of loads moved | Load records, ERP shipments |
| Tender acceptance | Accepted tenders divided by tenders offered | Tender emails, booking records |
| Response time | Time from tender to answer | Tender and acceptance timestamps |
| On-time pickup | Pickups within the agreed window | Rate confirmation, pickup records |
| On-time delivery | Deliveries by the agreed date and time | POD, receiver records |
| Paid against agreed | Amount paid minus rate confirmation amount | Rate confirmations, paid invoices |
| Invoice accuracy | Invoices matching on first check | Invoice audit results |
| Accessorials | Count and amount per load | Invoices |
| Claims | Count, amount and time to settle | Claim files |
| POD turnaround | Days from delivery to POD received | POD records |
| Shipper-side causes | Loads where the miss started at the shipper | Load notes, change history |
Agenda for each carrier conversation
| Topic | What to cover | Output |
|---|---|---|
| The data | Share the numbers by lane before the call; ask the carrier to check them | Agreed facts |
| What went well | Lanes and loads where the carrier performed | Lanes to grow |
| Problems | Specific misses, with dates, and what caused them | Agreed fixes |
| Shipper-side issues | What the carrier saw at your docks or in your orders | Your own fix list |
| Capacity next year | Which lanes and days the carrier wants more of | Lanes to offer |
| Rates | Expected changes, fuel and accessorial terms | Updated targets |
| Contacts | Dispatch, billing and claims contacts for next year | Updated contact list |
| Documents and invoices | POD timing, invoice format, payment terms | Clear expectations |
Decision table per lane
| Lane result | Typical decision |
|---|---|
| Carrier strong on service and paid cost | Keep or move up the ranking |
| Strong on service, high paid cost | Negotiate toward the target; keep as backup if no movement |
| Low paid cost, weak service | Move down; keep for non-critical loads if useful |
| Low acceptance as first choice | Move down so tenders start with a carrier that accepts |
| Not enough loads to judge | Keep current rank and review mid-year |
| No loads in a year | Re-engage with a specific lane or retire from the approved list |
| No approved carrier performing well | Trial a new carrier on the lane or run a bid |
A hypothetical lane decision
Consider a hypothetical lane from a plant in Ohio to a distribution center in Georgia, with 120 truckloads in the year across three carriers. Carrier A moved 70 loads with strong on-time delivery but paid cost averaging $180 over the rate confirmation because of repeated detention charges. Carrier B moved 40 loads at the agreed rate with weaker pickup timing. Carrier C moved 10 loads and accepted only half of its tenders. Checking the detention records shows most of A's charges came from long loading times at the plant. The decision: keep A first, fix the plant's loading process, keep B second and move C to backup. The example shows the method, not a real result.
How does Wilson, by Cartage, help with a year-end carrier review?
Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays freight for manufacturers and distributors, so the records a carrier review needs are created as the loads move. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward. Think of it as a free logistics department: what big shippers build over years, Wilson does from day one, in four parts.
The labor. Wilson does the work from the first quote to the final POD. It requests quotes from the company's approved carriers, compares them on total cost, negotiates toward the company's rate targets within approval limits and books with written acceptance and a rate confirmation. Rates outside the limits go to the logistics team. Wilson schedules pickups, tracks each load with the best source available and handles exceptions such as missed pickups, cancellations and delays. It follows up with carriers persistently by phone and email until it gets an answer, and it requests and files PODs.
The data. Wilson keeps every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact on record as it works, connected to the company's ERP. Every message, confirmation and change is kept in the shipment's change history, so the review can separate a carrier's miss from a change the team approved. Wilson does not keep a permanent scorecard or run recurring benchmarking by default, but it can produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs. That gives the review a year of tenders, rates, invoices and delivery records without rebuilding them from inboxes.
The output of the review fits how Wilson books. Booking uses a ranked list of carriers per lane, a waterfall, plus decision rules by lane and mode. The team sets the new order after the review. A new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it, so a trial carrier can be limited to specific lanes. Wilson does not vet or score carriers on its own; the company decides who is approved and where.
When the team changes a carrier or time on one load, Wilson treats it as a change to that load, not a permanent rule. If it looks like it should become a rule, Wilson asks the team whether to make it one. It never adopts it silently.
Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope.
The network. Wilson gets better freight rates on every lane because the shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's. The network includes carriers and brokers, and the company still approves who hauls its freight. Carriers keep their direct contracts and credit terms with the shipper, and Cartage takes no margin on the freight. Cartage can suggest additional carrier capacity for a weak lane, but the company approves each carrier before Wilson uses it.
The payments. Wilson audits every carrier invoice against the rate confirmation and the POD before money moves, then pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. Invoices over the agreed rate or outside the rules are held and flagged for a person. That audit history is the paid-against-agreed number a carrier review needs.
Control stays with the company. Wilson starts with assisted execution, the company sets approval limits, and routine actions can run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven.
Pricing
Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.
FAQs
Can Wilson give us the data for a year-end carrier review?
Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, can produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs. Because it quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays those loads, the tenders, rates, confirmations, invoices and changes are already on each shipment record. It does not keep a permanent scorecard by default.
How often should we review our carriers?
A full review once a year works for most shippers, with a short mid-year check on lanes that changed. Lanes with frequent problems may need a monthly look. The full review should end with a written ranking per lane.
Which carriers should be in the review?
Every carrier that moved meaningful volume, plus every carrier on the approved list. Carriers that moved nothing in a year still need a decision: re-engage on a specific lane or retire from the list.
What is the most important number in a carrier review?
There is no single number. For most shippers the core set is tender acceptance, on-time pickup and delivery, and paid cost against the rate confirmation, measured by lane. Claims matter when they happen.
Should we share the review results with carriers?
Yes. Send each important carrier its numbers before the meeting so it can check them. Carriers plan capacity around expected freight, and a clear conversation usually gets better service and rates than silence.
How do we handle misses that were our fault?
Mark them in the records and remove them from the carrier's numbers. Freight not ready, wrong weights and slow docks are common causes. List them as the shipper's own fixes for next year.
Is a year-end review the same as a freight bid?
No. A review starts from the carriers you already use and decides how to rank them. A bid asks carriers to price lanes from scratch. A review can show which lanes need a bid.
Can we limit a new carrier to a few lanes after the review?
Yes. With Wilson, a new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it. That lets the team trial a carrier on non-critical lanes before giving it more freight.
How long should we keep load records for reviews?
Keep at least the full year under review plus open claims. Under 49 U.S.C. 14706, carriers may not set less than nine months to file a claim or less than two years to sue after a written denial, so claim records should stay available at least that long.
Sources
- Cartage, Wilson product FAQ and product scope, October 2026: https://cartage.ai
- 49 U.S.C. 14706, liability of carriers under receipts and bills of lading (minimum periods to file a claim and to sue)
Let's review your carriers with a year of loads on the table. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
