We have accounts with a dozen carriers but use three. Does that matter?
Does it matter that most of your carrier accounts sit unused?
A distributor's lead carrier on its busiest outbound lane calls at 7:30 a.m.: no truck today. The coordinator opens the carrier list. There are twelve accounts. Three handle almost every load. Of the other nine, two were set up for a customer the company no longer serves, one was opened by someone who left last year and four have no notes at all. The coordinator emails two of them. One bounces. The other replies at noon with a rate from 2024 and asks for a new credit application.
Having accounts with a dozen carriers but using three matters when the unused accounts are treated as backups or options without being kept current. In that case, the company thinks it has twelve carriers and really has three. The unused accounts fail exactly when they are needed, because their contacts, rates, documents and payment details went stale while nobody was looking.
Twelve accounts is not too many, and three active carriers is not too few. Many shippers do well with a handful of core carriers. The problem is the gap between the list and reality. A carrier list should answer one question for every important lane: who do we call first, and who do we call next? If it can't, the extra accounts add risk and admin without adding coverage.
Three ways unused accounts cost money
- False coverage. The team plans as if it has backups. On a bad day, the backups don't answer, can't serve the lane or need paperwork first. The load ends up on an expensive spot option or misses its date.
- Missed price checks. If quote requests always go to the same three carriers, the company never learns whether one of the others would be cheaper on a lane. The core carriers know it, too.
- Hidden risk. An account nobody watches is an account where a changed payment detail, a lapsed certificate or a stale contact can slip through.
Why it happens
Carrier accounts are easy to open and rarely closed. One was set up for a special project, one for a new customer's lanes, one because a sales rep called on a quiet afternoon. Each made sense at the time. Without a regular review, the list grows and nobody owns the question of which accounts still earn their place.
Let's review your carrier list and which ones actually move freight. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers.
Book a demo →How do you find out which carrier accounts are really active?
Pull a year of loads and quote requests, count them by carrier and lane, and sort every account into one of four groups: core, backup, occasional and inactive. The data usually already exists in the ERP, freight invoices and email.
Step 1: Pull the load history
For the last twelve months, list every load with its carrier, lane, mode, date, cost and whether it delivered on time. Freight invoices are a good starting point, since every paid load has one. Add loads from the ERP or shipping records if some carriers bill differently.
Step 2: Pull the quote history
Loads show who won. Quotes show who was asked. For each carrier, count how many times it was asked for a quote, how often it answered and how often it won. A carrier that answers every request but never wins is different from one that was never asked.
Step 3: Build a lane-by-carrier view
Put lanes down the side and carriers across the top, with load counts in the cells. Most companies find the same picture: a few lanes carry most of the volume, a few carriers carry most of those lanes, and the rest of the grid is mostly empty.
Step 4: Sort each account
| Group | What it looks like | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Core | Moves loads every month on one or more lanes | Keep; set targets and review performance |
| Backup | Moved a few loads in the year, usually when a core carrier couldn't | Keep; rank as second or third choice on named lanes |
| Occasional | Moved one or two loads for a special case | Keep only if the special case will repeat; note the case |
| Inactive | No loads in twelve months | Re-test on a lane, pause or close |
Step 5: Talk to the people who book
The numbers miss context. Ask the coordinators why each carrier is used or avoided. "They're cheap but never answer the phone after 3 p.m." or "They're great on reefer but we stopped shipping reefer" belongs on the record. This is also where informal preferences surface, the ones that live in someone's head and leave when that person does.
A hypothetical example
Consider a hypothetical manufacturer with twelve carrier accounts and 1,100 loads a year. Three carriers moved 940 loads. Two moved 120 loads between them, mostly on days when a core carrier had no truck. One moved 25 loads on a single seasonal lane. One moved 15 loads for a customer that left. Five moved nothing.
The useful finding is not that five accounts are dead. It is that the two working backups cover only three of the company's eight main lanes. On the other five lanes, the company has no tested second choice. The cleanup should start there.
What goes stale on an account nobody uses?
Contacts, rates, documents, payment details, lane coverage and the carrier's own appetite for your freight all change while an account sits idle. The longer the gap, the more of them need checking before the next load.
| Item | How it goes stale | What breaks on the first load back |
|---|---|---|
| Contacts | People change jobs; shared inboxes are renamed | Quote request or tender goes to a dead address |
| Rates and tariffs | Contract rates expire; tariffs and fuel tables change | The quote or invoice doesn't match what the team expected |
| Credit and payment terms | Terms lapse or are reset after inactivity | Carrier asks for a new credit application before it will haul |
| Insurance certificate | Certificates expire and are renewed without the shipper seeing the new one | The company can't confirm current coverage |
| Payment details | Remit-to or bank details change | A payment goes to an old account, or a fraudulent change slips through |
| Lane coverage | Carrier changes terminals or service area | Carrier can no longer serve the lane |
| Equipment | Carrier changes its fleet or service mix | The equipment the lane needs isn't available |
| Your requirements | Your customers' receiving rules or labeling change | The carrier doesn't know the current rules |
Contacts
A contact that hasn't been used in a year is a guess. The person may have left, the dispatch inbox may route elsewhere, and the after-hours number may be disconnected. On a backup carrier, the contact is the most important piece, because backups are called under time pressure. For how an agent should behave when it doesn't have a contact, see what an AI agent should do when it doesn't know a carrier contact.
Rates
Contract rates have end dates. Tariff-based LTL pricing changes with general rate increases and discount updates. A rate sheet from two years ago tells the team almost nothing about today's price. If a carrier is a backup on a lane, ask it for a current rate on that lane at least once or twice a year, even if no load follows. The article on spot quotes and contract rates explains how the two kinds of rate behave.
Payment details
This is the riskiest item. A request to change a carrier's remit-to address or bank account should always be confirmed through a contact already on file, by phone, before anything changes. On an inactive account, nobody remembers what the old details were or who at the carrier normally sends billing messages. Treat any payment-detail change on a dormant account with extra care.
Your own requirements
Carriers that haven't hauled for you in a while don't know what changed: new customer appointment rules, new labeling requirements, a new dock schedule. The first load back should come with the current requirements, just as a new carrier's would.
What to send a carrier you haven't used in a year
Reviving an account works best as one short, specific message, sent before a load needs it. It should:
- Name the lanes you want the carrier to cover, with typical freight, volume and equipment.
- Ask for a current rate on each lane, valid for a stated period.
- Ask who to contact for quotes, dispatch, after-hours problems, billing and claims.
- Ask for the current insurance certificate and confirm the payment terms on file.
- Share your current pickup hours, customer appointment rules and labeling requirements.
Any reply that changes payment details should be confirmed by phone through a contact already on file, not through the email that asked for it. Record the answers on the carrier's record with the date. If the carrier doesn't reply within a couple of weeks, that is an answer too: it shouldn't be ranked as a backup on any lane until it does.
The cost of a stale backup on the day
Consider a hypothetical truckload lane where the first-choice carrier cancels at 7:30 a.m. With a tested backup, one call and a rate confirmation close the gap before 9:00. With a stale backup, the coordinator spends the morning on bounced emails and credit forms, then books a spot option at a premium in the afternoon, and the pickup slips a day. The difference rarely shows up in a freight report, but it shows up in the coordinator's day and the customer's delivery date.
Should you keep, rank or close each account?
Keep accounts that cover a lane you need, rank every kept carrier per lane, and pause or close the rest. The goal is a short list where every carrier has a role the team can name.
Rule 1: Every kept account needs a lane
An account without a lane is not a backup. For each carrier you keep, write the lanes it can serve and its rank on each: first choice, second, third. A carrier can be first on one lane and third on another.
Rule 2: Every important lane needs a tested backup
"Tested" means the backup has moved at least one load on that lane, or recently quoted it and confirmed it can serve it. A backup that has never moved your freight is a hope. The guide on backup carrier order of operations covers how to move down the list when the first choice can't cover.
Rule 3: Ask unused approved carriers for quotes on purpose
If some approved carriers never get asked, the company never learns what they would charge. Include them in quote requests on the lanes they can serve, at least some of the time. The question of which loads are worth comparing is covered in which loads are worth shopping for freight quotes.
Rule 4: Re-test before relying on an inactive carrier
Before an inactive carrier becomes a backup on a lane, confirm its contacts, current rate, payment details and documents, and give it a non-critical load or two. Treat it like a new carrier on that lane.
Rule 5: Close what you won't use
If a carrier serves no lane you ship and you can't see a reason it will, close or pause the account. Remove its contacts from active lists so nobody emails it by mistake, and record why it was closed.
Mistakes to avoid
- Keeping accounts "just in case." In practice, "just in case" accounts are the ones nobody can reach on the day.
- Ranking carriers by memory. Rankings that live in one coordinator's head disappear on that coordinator's day off.
- Ranking by price alone. Service, communication and how a carrier handles exceptions matter as much on many lanes.
- Letting a backup do all the bad loads. A carrier that only gets the hard, last-minute loads will price them accordingly, or stop answering.
- Reviewing the list and not the lanes. A list of twelve active carriers can still leave a key lane with no backup.
How ranking per lane looks
| Lane | First choice | Second choice | Third choice | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plant to Midwest DCs (LTL) | Carrier A | Carrier C | Carrier F | F re-tested last quarter |
| Plant to Southeast customers (FTL) | Carrier B | Carrier D | None tested | Find and test a third choice |
| Plant to West Coast (LTL) | Carrier C | Carrier A | Carrier H | H only for no-stack freight |
| Seasonal lane (FTL) | Carrier E | Carrier B | None | Review before season starts |
The letters stand for carriers on the company's approved list. A ranked list per lane like this one is what turns twelve accounts into real coverage.
What does a carrier list cleanup checklist look like?
A cleanup checklist covers each account, each lane and the records behind them. Run it once in full, then keep it current with a short quarterly check.
| Check | Question | Owner |
|---|---|---|
| Activity | How many loads and quotes did each carrier handle in the last twelve months? | Logistics |
| Lanes | Which lanes can each carrier serve, and on which does it actually move freight? | Logistics |
| Ranking | Does every important lane have a first choice and a tested backup? | Logistics manager |
| Contacts | Is there a confirmed contact for quotes, dispatch, after-hours, billing and claims? | Logistics |
| Rates | Is there a current rate or recent quote for each lane the carrier is ranked on? | Logistics |
| Documents | Is the current insurance certificate and carrier agreement on file? | Logistics or compliance |
| Payment details | Do remit-to and bank details match what was last confirmed? | Finance |
| Terms | Are credit and payment terms still active? | Finance |
| Requirements | Has the carrier received your current customer and dock rules? | Logistics |
| Inactive accounts | Which ones will be re-tested, paused or closed? | Logistics manager |
| Notes | Is the reason for each carrier's rank written down? | Logistics |
| Review date | When will the list be reviewed next? | Logistics manager |
Who owns the list
One person should own the carrier list and its rankings, usually the logistics manager. Coordinators suggest changes; the owner decides. Finance owns payment details and terms. Anyone who opens a new carrier account should add the lanes and rank at the same time, or the list starts drifting again.
How often to review
A full review once a year, ahead of contract or rate discussions, and a short quarterly check of the lanes with the most volume. Any time a backup is used, note how it went: that is the cheapest performance data a shipper can collect.
Adding a carrier after the cleanup
Cleanup often shows a lane with no tested backup. Adding a carrier there should follow the same steps as re-testing an inactive one: confirm contacts, rates, documents and payment details, then start on non-critical loads. The article on trialing a new carrier before critical loads covers the steps.
How does Wilson, by Cartage, use the carriers you already have?
Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that books from a ranked list of the company's approved carriers on each lane, requests quotes from them, follows up until they answer and keeps their contacts, rates and documents on record. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward.
Wilson works as a free logistics department for manufacturers and distributors: what big shippers build over years, Wilson does from day one. Its four parts each help keep a carrier list working.
The labor
The labor is the quoting, booking and follow-up that keeps carriers active. Wilson does the work start to finish, from the first quote to the final POD: quotes, bookings, paperwork, tracking and carrier follow-ups, by email, phone calls, texts, Slack and Teams. It requests quotes from the company's approved carriers, compares them on total cost and negotiates toward the company's rate targets within approval limits. Booking follows a ranked list of carriers per lane, a waterfall, plus decision rules by lane and mode. When the first choice can't cover a load, Wilson moves to the next approved carrier within the rules or after approval. It follows up with carriers by phone and email, with persistence rules per carrier, until it gets an answer. The team doesn't chase carriers.
The data
The data is the carrier list, kept current as Wilson works. Wilson keeps every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact on record, connected to the company's ERP. It keeps memories and rules too, such as "this carrier gets first look on one lane," learned from its own work or added by the team, and the team can edit them. When a change on one load looks like it should become a rule, Wilson asks the team before making it one. The company owns its carriers, rules, approval limits and contacts, and records are searchable and exportable with change history. Wilson does not keep a permanent scorecard by default, but it can produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs, which is the starting point for a cleanup. Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope.
The network
The network adds coverage where the list is thin. The shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's, which can bring better freight rates on its lanes. The network includes carriers and brokers. Cartage can suggest additional carrier capacity, but the company approves each carrier before Wilson uses it, and a new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it. Shippers can keep their own carriers, with their direct contracts and credit terms.
The payments
The payments protect the account details that drift on unused carriers. Wilson audits every freight invoice against the load before money moves, then pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. Invoices over the rate or outside the rules wait for a person. A change in a carrier's remit-to or bank details is flagged to the team as a possible fraud signal, and Wilson does not act on it alone.
Wilson starts with assisted execution. The company sets approval limits, and routine actions can run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven. Wilson handles LTL, FTL, ocean, drayage, parcel and cross-border freight. It is not a freight broker or a customs broker, and it does not vet or score carriers by default.
Pricing
Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.
FAQs
Can Wilson use the carrier accounts we already have?
Yes. Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, books only carriers the company has approved, using a ranked list per lane and the company's decision rules. Shippers can keep their own carriers, with their direct contracts and credit terms; the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them.
How many carriers should a shipper have?
There is no right number. What matters is that every important lane has a first choice and at least one tested backup, and that every account on the list has a lane it serves.
Is it bad to have carrier accounts we never use?
Not in itself. It becomes a problem when the team counts them as backups without keeping contacts, rates, documents and payment details current. Then they fail on the day they are needed.
How do we know if a backup carrier will actually work?
Test it. A backup has moved at least one load on the lane, or recently quoted it and confirmed it can serve it. Ask it for a current rate on its lanes at least once or twice a year.
Should we close carrier accounts we haven't used in a year?
Close or pause them if they serve no lane you ship and you see no reason to use them. If one could cover a lane with no backup, re-test it instead.
How often should we review our carrier list?
A full review once a year and a short quarterly check on the highest-volume lanes. Record how each backup performed whenever it is used.
Can Wilson tell us which carriers perform best on each lane?
Wilson can produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs. It doesn't keep a permanent scorecard by default, and the company decides the rankings.
What should we check before using a carrier we haven't used in a while?
Confirm the contact for dispatch and billing, get a current rate, check the insurance certificate and terms, and confirm payment details through a contact already on file. Share your current customer and dock requirements before the first load.
Will Wilson add carriers to our list without asking?
No. Cartage can suggest additional carrier capacity, but the company approves each carrier before Wilson uses it, and a new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it.
Sources
- Cartage, Wilson product FAQ and product scope, October 2026: https://cartage.ai
Let's review your carrier list and which ones actually move freight. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
