Our team keeps skipping the routing guide. How do we get loads booked in the right order?
Short answer
Turn the routing guide into a short ranked list of carriers for each lane. Offer each load to the first carrier, then the next one, in order. Allow skips only for a few written reasons, and record the reason on the load. Review the skips each month and fix the list. Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, books from this ranked list and asks your team before it skips a carrier.
Book 15 minutes with the team →Our team keeps skipping the routing guide. How do we get loads booked in the right order?
It is month-end at a manufacturer. The logistics manager pulls a report of last month's outbound truckloads. On the lane from the main plant to a large customer in Ohio, the routing guide names a primary carrier with a negotiated contract rate. Only 41% of loads went to that carrier. The rest went to three other carriers, two of which are not in the guide for that lane. Nobody wrote down why. When the manager asks, the answers are vague: "They were faster to answer." "I always use them for that customer." "The primary said no once, so I stopped asking."
To get loads booked in the right order, turn the routing guide into a ranked carrier list for each lane, write the few reasons that allow skipping a rank, record every skip on the load and review the skips each month. When the order is clear and exceptions leave a record, the team follows it. When the guide is a long document that nobody opens at 3 p.m. on a busy day, people book whoever answers first.
The problem is rarely the routing guide's content. It is the gap between the document and the moment of booking. A coordinator with ten open loads does not stop to read a PDF. They call the carrier they trust, because that has worked before.
Why booking order matters
Skipping the guide has costs that show up later:
- Higher freight spend. The primary carrier often has the best rate on the lane. Each skip may cost the difference between that rate and a spot quote.
- Broken commitments. If the company promised a carrier a share of volume on a lane in exchange for a rate, skipping it weakens that deal and the next rate review.
- Hidden risk. Loads go to carriers that the guide did not rank for that lane, sometimes for freight they are not set up to handle well.
- Bad data. When nobody records why a load moved, the company cannot tell whether the primary carrier is failing or simply not being asked.
What "the right order" means
The right order is the one the company chose for each lane, based on cost, service and capacity. It is not "cheapest first" and not "whoever answers fastest". A good guide already explains how to build it; see how to write a routing guide for carriers and suppliers. This article is about the next problem: getting the team to book in that order, every day.
Want to see where your bookings drift from the guide?
Let's review your routing guide and last month's bookings. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers.15 minutes with the team behind Wilson. No prep needed.
Book 15 minutes →Why do coordinators skip the routing guide?
Coordinators skip the routing guide when following it is slower, riskier or less clear than calling a carrier they know. Each reason below points to a fix.
Habit and a favorite carrier
Every team has carriers it trusts. A coordinator who has worked with one dispatcher for years will call them first. That relationship has value. The problem is when it overrides a lane decision the company made on purpose. The fix is not to ban the favorite carrier. It is to rank it where it belongs on each lane, so the trust is part of the guide instead of a way around it.
Speed
Following the guide can mean offering the load to the first carrier, waiting, then moving to the second. On a busy afternoon, a coordinator may skip straight to a carrier that answers in five minutes. The fix is a written deadline for each rank. If the first carrier does not accept within the time the company sets, the load moves to the next carrier. The team stops guessing how long to wait.
The primary carrier keeps rejecting loads
If the first carrier on a lane rejects a lot of tenders, coordinators learn to skip it. That is a reasonable reaction to a real problem, but it should not happen silently. Rejections belong in the record. If they repeat, the lane needs a new order or a talk with the carrier.
The guide is out of date
Carriers leave lanes, rates change and new customers open new destinations. A guide written two years ago may not list the lanes the team ships on today. When the guide has no answer, people make one up. The fix is an owner and a review schedule.
The guide is hard to use
A 30-page document with tables by region, weight and mode is hard to read at the moment of booking. The team needs one line per lane: first, second, third, with the rules next to it. If the guide cannot answer "who do I offer this load to?" in a few seconds, it will be skipped.
Requests from outside logistics
Sometimes the skip does not start with the coordinator. A sales rep promises a customer that "the usual carrier" will deliver. A plant supervisor calls a carrier directly because a truck is needed in an hour. A customer service rep books a carrier from an old email thread. Each of these feels like a one-time favor. Together, they make the routing guide optional. The fix is to route every booking request through the same place and to write down who can ask for a specific carrier, and when. A request from sales can still be honored. It just needs a name and a reason on the load, like any other skip.
No consequence and no record
If nobody looks at which carrier took each load, nobody notices the drift. Coordinators are not ignoring the guide on purpose. They are doing what keeps freight moving, and no one has asked them to do otherwise.
How do you turn a routing guide into a ranked list per lane?
Turn each lane in the guide into an ordered list of approved carriers, with decision rules that say when to move down the list. This is the waterfall. It is simple enough to follow on every load and clear enough to check afterward.
Step 1: Define lanes the way you book
Use the same lane definition the team uses when it books: origin, destination, mode and service. Add weight or pallet limits where they change the carrier choice. A lane that is too broad, such as "anything to the Midwest", hides real differences. A lane that is too narrow creates hundreds of rows nobody maintains.
Step 2: Rank the approved carriers on each lane
For each lane, list the approved carriers in the order the company wants to use them. Base the order on total cost, service history, capacity and any volume commitment. Two or three carriers per lane is common for steady lanes. Lanes with irregular volume may use spot quotes from a set of approved carriers instead of a fixed order.
Only approved carriers belong on the list. A carrier that is approved for one lane is not automatically approved for every lane. If the company is trying a new carrier, rank it only on the lanes where it is being tested. The guide on keeping approved carriers approved in automated booking explains why that boundary matters.
Step 3: Write the decision rules
The ranking tells the team who to ask first. The rules tell them when to move on. Common rules include:
- Acceptance deadline. How long to wait for each carrier before offering the load to the next one.
- Rejection. If the carrier declines in writing, move to the next rank.
- Rate. If the carrier asks for more than the lane limit, the load either moves on or goes to a person for approval.
- Pickup date. If the carrier cannot pick up on the required date, the team decides whether to accept a later date or move on.
- Equipment or service. If the carrier cannot provide the equipment or service the load needs, move on.
- End of the list. If no ranked carrier accepts, the load goes to a person, who may approve spot quotes from other approved carriers.
Step 4: Put the list where booking happens
The ranked list should live in the same place the team books loads. A list in a separate document will drift. When a lane changes, update the list first, then tell the team.
An example ranked list
The table below is hypothetical. It shows the format, not real carriers or rates.
| Lane | Rank 1 | Rank 2 | Rank 3 | Wait for each rank | If no one accepts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main plant to Ohio customer DC, dry van truckload | Carrier A, contract rate | Carrier B, contract rate | Carrier C, quote each time | 1 hour | Logistics manager approves spot quotes |
| Main plant to Texas DC, dry van truckload | Carrier B | Carrier D | Spot quotes from approved carriers | 2 hours | Logistics manager decides |
| Warehouse to Southeast, LTL under 6 pallets | Carrier E | Carrier F | None | 30 minutes | Coordinator requests quotes from approved LTL carriers |
| Warehouse to West Coast, reefer | Carrier G | Carrier H | None | 1 hour | Escalate the same day |
What to do when a carrier offers a later date
A ranked carrier may accept but say it can only pick up a day later. That is not an acceptance of the load as ordered. The team should see the option, decide whether the later date works for the customer and keep the agreed date unchanged until someone decides. If the later date does not work, the load moves to the next rank.
How should exceptions to the routing guide be handled and recorded?
Allow a short list of written reasons to skip a rank, require approval for anything else and record the reason on every load that moves down the list. That keeps the guide flexible enough for real freight and strict enough to be useful.
Valid reasons to skip
Most routing guides can use a small set of reasons:
- The carrier rejected the tender.
- The carrier did not answer before the deadline.
- The carrier cannot pick up on the required date.
- The carrier cannot provide the equipment or service.
- The carrier's rate is above the lane limit.
- A customer or manager asked for a specific carrier on this load.
The last reason is valid, but it should name who asked. If a sales rep or customer asks for the same carrier every time, that may be a lane rule waiting to be written.
Reasons that need approval
Some reasons are not valid on their own:
- "They answer faster."
- "I always use them for this customer."
- "The primary rejected one load last month."
These may point to a real problem. If the primary is slow, the deadline may be too long. If a customer prefers a carrier, the ranking may need to change. But a coordinator should not change the lane order alone, on one load, without a record.
Reason codes in one table
| Reason code | Example | Needs approval? | What to review |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rejected | Carrier declined the tender by email | No | Rejection count per carrier per lane |
| No answer | No reply within the deadline | No | Whether the deadline fits the lane |
| Date | Carrier can only pick up the next day | Team decides on the date | How often the carrier lacks capacity on the date |
| Equipment | No reefer available | No | Whether the lane needs another carrier with that equipment |
| Over limit | Rate above the lane limit | Yes, for booking above the limit | Whether the limit or the ranking is out of date |
| Requested | Customer asked for a specific carrier | No, but name who asked | Whether this should become a lane rule |
| Other | Any reason not listed | Yes | Whether the guide is missing a rule |
Change on one load or change to the rule?
When a coordinator changes the carrier on one load, that is a decision about that load. It should not quietly become the new order for the lane. If the same change happens on several loads, ask whether the lane order should change. Then update the ranking on purpose, with a date and an owner. This is how a routing guide learns without drifting. For more on how carrier preferences can become written lane rules, see whether an AI agent can learn which carriers you trust.
How do you check that the routing guide is being followed?
Check routing guide use every month with a few simple numbers and a short review of the skips. The goal is to fix the guide where it is wrong and to support the team where it is right.
Numbers to track by lane
- Share of loads booked with the first-ranked carrier.
- Share booked with each lower rank.
- Share booked with a carrier not on the lane list.
- Skips by reason code.
- Rejections by carrier.
- Average cost per load by rank, compared with the first-ranked carrier's rate.
These numbers do not need special software. A simple export of loads with carrier, lane and reason code is enough to start. What matters is that the reason is recorded on each load.
A monthly review checklist
| Question | What it tells you | Action if the answer is bad |
|---|---|---|
| Which lanes book with rank 1 less than most of the time? | Where the guide does not match reality | Talk to the carrier or change the order |
| Which carriers reject the most loads? | Capacity or price problems | Review the rate or the lane |
| Which loads went to carriers not on the list? | Unapproved bookings | Find the reason and close the gap |
| Which reason codes are "Other"? | Missing rules | Write the rule or reject the reason |
| Which "Requested" carriers repeat? | Hidden lane preferences | Decide whether to make it a lane rule |
| Has any lane had no booking for months? | Dead lanes | Remove or archive it |
| Are new lanes missing from the guide? | Gaps | Add them with a ranking |
How to roll out the change
Start with the lanes that carry the most volume or where the drift costs the most. Rank the carriers, write the rules and the reason codes, and run the lanes for a few weeks. Then review the skips with the team. Ask what made the guide hard to follow. Fix the list and add the next lanes.
Keep the backup plan connected
A ranked list is also a backup plan. When the first carrier fails after booking, the next rank is the natural first call. The guide on the order of operations when your first carrier fails covers that step. Keep both in the same place so the team does not have two different lists.
Tell the carriers
Carriers respond better when they know where they stand. Tell each carrier which lanes it is ranked on and how long it has to accept. A carrier that knows it has an hour to answer is more likely to answer within the hour.
How does Wilson, by Cartage, follow a routing guide on every load?
Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays freight for manufacturers and distributors, and it books each load from the company's ranked carrier list for that lane. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward. Think of it as a free logistics department: what big shippers build over years, Wilson does from day one, in four parts.
The labor. Wilson does the work from the first quote to the final POD: quotes, bookings, paperwork, tracking and carrier follow-ups, by email, phone calls, texts, Slack and Microsoft Teams. Booking uses a ranked list of carriers per lane, a waterfall, plus decision rules by lane and mode. Wilson offers the load to the carriers in the order the company set. It follows up with carriers by phone and email until it gets an answer. It books with written acceptance and a rate confirmation, and it schedules the pickup. Wilson checks carrier availability before booking. If a carrier says it cannot pick up until a later day, Wilson does not accept that silently. It presents the option to the team, updates the expected date and leaves the agreed date unchanged. The team decides. Rates outside the approval limits go to the logistics team.
The data. Wilson keeps every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact on record as it works, connected to the company's ERP. Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Every message, confirmation and change is kept in the shipment's change history, so the team can see which carrier was asked, what it answered and why the load moved down the list. When the team changes the carrier on one load, Wilson treats it as a change to that load, not a permanent rule. If it looks like it should become a rule, Wilson asks the team whether to make it one. It never adopts it silently. A new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it. Wilson can also produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs, which helps with the monthly review.
Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope.
The network. Wilson gets better freight rates on every lane because the shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's. The network includes carriers and brokers. The company still approves who hauls its freight, and it decides where any network carrier sits in the ranking.
The payments. Wilson audits every carrier invoice against the rate confirmation and the POD before money moves, then pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. Invoices over the rate or outside the rules wait for a person.
Control stays with the company. Wilson starts with assisted execution, the company sets approval limits, and routine actions can run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven. For how Wilson picks the carrier for the next load on a lane, see lane-specific carrier selection for the next load.
Pricing
Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.
See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers.15 minutes with the team behind Wilson. No prep needed.
Book 15 minutes →FAQs
Can Wilson follow our routing guide on every load?
Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, books from a ranked list of approved carriers per lane, plus decision rules by lane and mode. It offers each load in the order the company set and records why a load moved down the list. Rates outside the approval limits go to the logistics team.
Why does our team keep skipping the routing guide?
Usually because following it is slower or less clear than calling a known carrier. Common causes are habit, a favorite carrier, an outdated guide, a primary carrier that rejects loads and no record of skips. Each cause has a different fix.
What is a routing guide waterfall?
A waterfall is a ranked list of carriers for a lane. The load goes to the first carrier, then the second if the first declines or does not answer in time, and so on. Decision rules say when to move down the list.
How long should we wait for each carrier to accept?
Set the wait by lane, based on how far ahead loads are booked and how fast carriers usually answer. A same-day load needs a short wait. A load booked days ahead can wait longer. Write the time down so nobody has to guess.
Should coordinators be allowed to skip the first carrier?
Yes, for a few written reasons such as rejection, no answer by the deadline, no capacity on the date or missing equipment. Other reasons should need approval. Every skip should be recorded on the load.
What if a customer always wants a specific carrier?
Record who asked on each load. If the request repeats, decide whether to make it a lane rule for that customer. Then rank that carrier first on that customer's lane instead of treating it as an exception every time.
What happens when no ranked carrier accepts the load?
The load goes to a person. That person may approve spot quotes from other approved carriers or change the pickup date with the customer. The guide should name who decides.
Does Wilson change the carrier order on its own?
No. When the team changes the carrier on one load, Wilson treats it as a change to that load. If it looks like it should become a rule, Wilson asks the team whether to make it one. It never adopts it silently.
How often should we update the routing guide?
Review skips every month and update lanes where the first carrier is skipped most of the time. Do a full review at least once a year, often around carrier rate talks.
Can Wilson add a new carrier to only a few lanes?
Yes. A new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it, so a carrier on trial can be limited to specific lanes. The company approves every carrier before Wilson uses it.
Sources
- Cartage, Wilson product FAQ and product scope, October 2026: https://cartage.ai
Let's review your routing guide and last month's bookings. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
