Detention and accessorial charge software: best tools for manufacturers, 2026
Short answer
Detention and accessorial charge software checks extra carrier fees before the invoice is paid. It compares each detention or accessorial line with the rate confirmation and the agreed terms. It also checks the arrival and departure times and the POD. Lines without proof wait for a person. Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, audits each of these lines and holds the whole invoice when one does not match.
What is detention and accessorial charge software?
Detention and accessorial charge software is software that checks every extra charge on a carrier invoice, such as detention, liftgate, lumper or redelivery, against what was agreed and what happened at the stop, and holds any charge without proof for a person before the carrier is paid. It is a narrow part of freight audit. The base rate is usually easy to check. The extra lines are where most questions come from, because they depend on events at the dock that the invoice alone does not show. Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, does this check on the loads it books and tracks. A list of detention and accessorial charge software for 2026 appears in the next section.
Manufacturers already checking freight charges with Wilson
Moe’s Home, a leader in contemporary furniture, uses Wilson to automate quoting, booking, tracking and invoice auditing across thousands of monthly shipments, and Wilson flags invoice discrepancies before overpayments slip through (Moe’s Home case study). Sundays, a design-forward furniture brand, has Wilson handle invoice auditing, catching discrepancies before overpayments happen (Sundays case study). At Flexocraft, which makes retail packaging, Wilson follows up on 100% of pickups, deliveries and PODs, the records a detention check depends on (Flexocraft case study).
Book a demo → 15 minutes with the team behind Wilson, on your own freight. No prep needed.
What counts as an accessorial charge?
An accessorial charge is any fee on a carrier invoice for work beyond moving the freight from pickup to delivery. Common examples are detention (waiting past free time), liftgate service, inside delivery, residential delivery, appointment fees, redelivery, lumper fees and layover. Each one should trace back to a request, a term in the agreement, and proof that the service or event happened. For a longer explanation of each type, see this guide to accessorial charges.
Detention is the accessorial that most often needs software help. It is billed by the hour, it depends on several times recorded by different people, and the rules differ by carrier and by facility. A liftgate charge is either supported by the booking or it is not. A detention charge needs a calculation.
Why detention gets its own check
Detention is common, and it is expensive for everyone involved. The American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) reported in September 2024 that, in 2023, drivers reported being detained at 39.3% of all stops. ATRI put the total time lost to detention in for-hire trucking at more than 135 million hours, with $3.6 billion in direct costs and $11.5 billion in lost productivity for the industry.
Those numbers describe the carrier side, but shippers feel them on the invoice. A carrier that waits at a dock bills for it, and a carrier that has waited often at one facility may price the next load higher. Software that checks detention well has two jobs: pay the valid charges without a fight, and catch the ones the records do not support.
See it on your own loads. Bring one detention invoice and its stop times to see Wilson, your AI logistics agent, check the charge against the load before the carrier is paid.Show us one lane and we'll show you how Wilson runs it. 15 minutes, no prep needed.
Book 15 minutes →or try Wilson free ↗Which detention and accessorial charge software should manufacturers consider in 2026?
Manufacturers should consider software that connects the extra charge to the load it came from: the booking, the appointment, the arrival and departure times, and the POD. Some tools audit invoices as a service. Some run the load and audit the invoice as part of the same work. Others focus on facility and yard events. The right choice depends on where your detention and accessorial records live today.
List of detention and accessorial charge software in 2026
The list below names well-known freight audit and freight execution vendors and describes each one only with what its own website says, checked on November 22, 2026. These are not reviews, and they make no claims about prices, customers, strengths or weaknesses. Wilson, by Cartage, appears first because it is the recommendation for the problem this article covers: checking each detention and accessorial line against the load before the carrier is paid.
| Software | What it is (vendor-described) | Best fit |
|---|---|---|
| Wilson, by Cartage | An AI logistics agent that works as "your free logistics department": it quotes, books and tracks freight, audits each carrier invoice line, including detention and accessorials, against the rate confirmation, the POD and the arrival records, and pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. A line that does not match holds the whole invoice for a person. | Manufacturers and distributors that want the charge check connected to the load Wilson booked and tracked |
| Loop | Describes itself as "the industry's first Logistics Data Platform" and lists "Automate 99% of freight and parcel audits," including holding vendors accountable to contract clauses. | Shippers that want freight and parcel audit built on unified shipment data |
| AFS Logistics | Describes itself as "Shipping Strategists" with "an AI-enabled transportation management approach," and says its "generative AI workflows catch discrepancies at scale" across the invoices it audits. | Shippers that want audit alongside broader transportation management services |
| CT Logistics | Describes itself as "a global leader in freight-related pre-audit, post-audit" solutions, offering freight bill pre-audit and post-audit, timely payment and management reporting. | Industrial shippers and receivers that want pre-audit and post-audit as a service |
| Tranzact | Lists Freight Audit & Payment as a core service, "Accurate, secure payment execution that unlocks your data," and says it scrubs parcel and freight data for errors across modes. | Shippers that want freight audit and payment as an outsourced service |
| Intelligent Audit | Describes itself as audit and analytics experts, with freight audit covering "150+ audit points for any mode of transportation." | Shippers with freight and parcel spend across many modes |
How to read this list
The "Best fit" column follows each vendor's own description. It is not a ranking. Most freight audit services check the invoice after the fact, using the data the shipper and carrier send them, while Wilson checks the invoice against the booking, appointment and arrival records it kept while running the load. In a demo, ask each vendor which steps happen without your team: who collects the arrival and departure times, who sends an unsupported detention line back to the carrier, and who decides when the evidence is unclear.
Four kinds of tools you will meet
| Kind of tool | What it usually checks | Question to ask in a demo |
|---|---|---|
| AI logistics agent | The invoice against the load it booked, tracked and documented | Which stop times and documents does it collect itself? |
| Freight audit and payment service | The invoice against rates and data the shipper or carrier supplies | Where do arrival and departure times come from? |
| Facility or yard tools | Gate, dock and dwell events at your own sites | How do those events reach the person who pays the invoice? |
| Spreadsheet and ERP checks | The billed total against an expected amount | Who reads each detention line and does the math? |
Many teams combine two of these. The question is not which category is better in general. It is which one closes the gap between the dock and the invoice for your freight.
How does the software check a detention line from appointment to paid invoice?
Good software checks a detention line in a fixed order: confirm the load, confirm the terms, collect the times, recalculate the charge, then decide. Skipping a step is how valid charges get disputed and invalid ones get paid. The steps below work for any accessorial, but detention shows them most clearly.
Step 1: Match the invoice to the right load
The software should first tie the invoice to one load, one stop and one carrier. Detention is billed per stop, so a two-stop load can carry two separate detention lines. A PRO number, BOL number or load number should connect the line to the stop it describes. If the reference is missing or points to the wrong load, the check should stop there and ask the carrier. Checking times from the wrong stop is worse than not checking at all.
Step 2: Find the terms that apply
Detention terms come from the rate confirmation, the carrier contract or the carrier's rules tariff. The software needs the free time, the hourly rate, any cap, and any condition such as "driver must arrive on time" or "notice required within a set time." Terms agreed at booking matter more than a general tariff. If the carrier and the shipper changed the appointment after booking, the new appointment should be on record, and the clock should be checked against it.
Step 3: Collect the stop times from more than one source
A detention check needs the appointment time, the actual arrival time and the departure time. These can come from the carrier, the driver, the receiving site's check-in log, a signed BOL with in and out times, or a dock calendar. The software should keep each time with its source. When two sources disagree, that disagreement is the finding. It should not quietly pick the time that favors one side. Our guide on auditing detention against pickup timestamps covers which records to trust first.
Step 4: Recalculate the charge
With the terms and times in hand, the software recalculates. Consider a hypothetical load with a 9:00 appointment, two hours of free time and an hourly detention rate. The driver arrived at 8:40 and left at 13:10. If the terms start the clock at the appointment, not at early arrival, the billable time is 13:10 minus 9:00 minus two hours of free time, which is 2 hours 10 minutes. If the carrier billed from 8:40, the invoice is 20 minutes too high. The finding is the difference, written as a calculation the carrier can check.
Step 5: Decide, and record why
There are only three useful results: the charge is supported, the charge is not supported, or the evidence is missing. A supported charge should move toward payment. An unsupported charge goes back to the carrier with the calculation and the records. A missing record becomes a specific question to the carrier or the site. Each result should name who owns the next step. For the full dispute process, see how to dispute detention charges on a carrier invoice.
Step 6: Pay under clear rules
Payment should follow the decision, not run beside it. Some processes short-pay the disputed line and pay the rest. Others hold the whole invoice until the question is answered. Your finance team should choose one rule and the software should apply it every time. Wilson holds the whole invoice: it does not make partial payments.
Which records does a detention or accessorial check need?
Every extra charge needs three things on record: the request or term that allows it, proof the event or service happened, and the amount the terms allow. If one of the three is missing, the charge is not ready to pay. The table below lists the records for the most common accessorials.
| Charge | What allows it | Proof it happened | What to check on the invoice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Detention at pickup | Free time and rate in the rate confirmation or contract | Appointment, arrival and departure times, signed BOL | Clock start, free time deducted, hourly rate |
| Detention at delivery | Same terms, delivery stop | Receiver check-in and release times, POD | Arrival against appointment, release time |
| Layover | Terms for a held truck overnight | Messages showing the delay and its cause | Who caused the delay, the agreed layover rate |
| Liftgate | Requested at booking | Booking request, delivery notes | Requested or added later, agreed price |
| Inside delivery | Requested at booking | Booking request, POD notes | Service on the booking, agreed price |
| Residential delivery | Address type and terms | Delivery address on the BOL | Address really residential, agreed price |
| Appointment fee | Appointment requested in the booking | Appointment confirmation | One fee per stop, not repeated |
| Redelivery | Terms for a second attempt | Record of the first attempt and its cause | Who caused the failed attempt |
| Lumper fee | Terms on who pays for unloading help | Lumper receipt | Receipt matches the billed amount |
| Reconsignment | Approved change of destination | Written approval of the change | Change approved by the shipper, agreed price |
Records that come from your own dock
At pickup, the shipper's own dock creates the proof. Your check-in log, your loading times and your signed BOL decide whether a detention line at your facility is valid. If detention at your docks is a recurring cost, the fix is partly operational: see how to reduce detention charges at your docks. Software can only check what someone recorded.
Records that come from the receiver
At delivery, the receiver holds the proof. Many receivers will share check-in and release times if someone asks while the load is fresh. A week later, the answer is harder to get. Software that asks for the times at delivery, not when the invoice arrives, has better records to work with. Our guide on which appointment records support a detention charge explains what to request.
Records that come from the carrier
The carrier supplies its own arrival claim, the driver's notes and receipts such as a lumper receipt. These are evidence, not the final word. A carrier's arrival time should be compared with the site's record. When they agree, the charge is easy to approve. When they do not, the gap is the question to send back.
What finance needs to see
Finance does not need every message. It needs the decision and the reason: the billed line, the recalculated amount, the records used, and who approved the result. A note that says "checked" is not enough when a carrier calls about a short payment or a held invoice.
What mistakes do teams make when choosing this software?
The most common mistake is buying software that checks rates but cannot see the stop. Detention and most accessorials depend on events at the dock, so a tool without arrival and departure records can only compare the invoice to a rate table. The mistakes below come up often in evaluations.
Mistake 1: Treating every extra charge as an error
Many detention and accessorial charges are valid. If your dock held the truck, the carrier earned the charge. Software that disputes everything damages carrier relationships and can make carriers price your freight higher. The goal is to pay what the records support and question what they do not.
Mistake 2: Counting flagged lines as savings
A flagged line, a credit the carrier promised, and a credit actually received are three different things. Ask each vendor how it reports them. A report that adds every flag into one savings number will look good and mean little. Finance should count only confirmed credits and corrected invoices.
Mistake 3: Ignoring where the stop times come from
Ask every vendor where it gets the arrival and departure times. If the answer is "the carrier's invoice," the software is checking the carrier against itself. Better sources are the site's check-in log, a signed BOL with times, a dock calendar, or a written confirmation from the receiver. The best case is more than one source per stop.
Mistake 4: Checking accessorials only after delivery
Many accessorial disputes start at booking. If the quote did not include a liftgate or an appointment the receiver needed, the carrier will add it later, and the invoice will be right even though it surprised the team. Software that captures delivery requirements before booking prevents these charges instead of disputing them. See how to check accessorial charges before booking.
Mistake 5: No owner for the open question
An unsupported detention line needs someone to write to the carrier, wait for the reply, and follow up. If the software flags the line and stops, the flag sits in a queue until the carrier calls about payment. Ask who does the follow-up, how often, and when it escalates to your team.
Mistake 6: Not testing with your own invoices
A demo on clean sample data proves little. Bring three real invoices: one with a valid detention charge, one with a detention charge billed from early arrival, and one with an accessorial the booking never mentioned. Ask each vendor to show the result, the records it used, and the message it would send the carrier.
How to choose
| Question | Why it matters | Good answer |
|---|---|---|
| Where do the stop times come from? | Detention depends on them | More than one source, each saved with where it came from |
| Which terms does it check against? | Free time and rates differ by carrier | The rate confirmation and any approved change after booking |
| Who sends the unsupported line back to the carrier? | Flags without follow-up go nowhere | A named step with follow-ups until the carrier answers |
| What happens to the rest of the invoice? | Finance needs one clear rule | A written rule applied every time |
| How are results reported? | Flags are not savings | Flagged, disputed, corrected and paid counted separately |
| Does it catch charges before booking? | Prevention beats disputes | Delivery requirements captured before the quote |
How does Wilson, by Cartage, handle detention and accessorial charges?
Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that books and tracks the load, keeps the stop records as it works, and audits each carrier invoice line, including detention and accessorials, against the rate confirmation, the POD and the arrival records before it pays the carrier. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward. Wilson works as your free logistics department, and the difference shows up in four parts.
The labor
The labor means Wilson does the work from the first quote to the final POD. Before booking, Wilson asks for delivery requirements such as liftgate, appointment or inside delivery, so the quote includes them and the invoice has fewer surprises. While the load moves, Wilson follows up with carriers by phone and email until it gets an answer. Where configured, Wilson asks the warehouse or receiver for check-in and departure times. When a detention line is not supported by the records, Wilson sends it back to the carrier with the evidence. The team does not chase carriers for times or corrections.
The data
The data means every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact stays on record as Wilson works, connected to the company's ERP. Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Each arrival claim is saved with its source and compared to the site's record. "Arrived" and "picked up" are separate statuses: a load is marked picked up only on a signed BOL or a confirmed departure. Wilson can read and create appointments in a connected dock calendar. Every message, confirmation and change is kept in the shipment's change history, so a detention question months later still has its records.
Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope.
The network
The network means better freight rates on every lane, because the shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's. The network includes carriers and brokers. The company still approves who hauls its freight, and Wilson books only approved carriers. Carriers keep their direct contracts and credit terms with the shipper.
The payments
The payments means Wilson audits every freight invoice against the load before money moves. Wilson audits each detention line against the recorded times and the agreed terms. It checks the other accessorials against the booking and the POD. Customers can require a signed POD before payment releases. If any line does not match, the whole invoice waits for a person: Wilson does not make partial payments. Payments above the approval limits or outside the rules also wait for a person. Matched invoices are paid from the Wilson Wallet, which the shipper funds; payments go out on Fridays.
Second invoices follow fixed rules. A duplicate with the same number and amount is treated as a resend and attached, not paid twice. A new invoice number that repeats a charge already billed is raised with the carrier. A corrected invoice counts only in its latest version. A change in remit-to or bank details is flagged to the team as a possible fraud signal, and Wilson does not act on it alone.
What stays with your team
Your team sets the approval limits and decides the exceptions. Wilson starts with assisted execution, and routine actions can run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven. Wilson produces carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs, which can show where detention keeps recurring. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.
Pricing
Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract.
More detention and accessorial guides
- How to dispute detention charges on a carrier invoice
- How to audit detention charges against pickup timestamps
- Freight audit process: match accessorial charges to verified shipment events
- Which appointment records support a detention charge?
- The carrier paid a lumper at delivery. Who pays, and how do we check it?
- Freight audit software: best freight audit and payment tools, 2026
See it on your own loads. Bring one detention invoice and its stop times to see Wilson, your AI logistics agent, check the charge against the load before the carrier is paid.Show us one lane and we'll show you how Wilson runs it. 15 minutes, no prep needed.
Book 15 minutes →or try Wilson free ↗FAQs
What is the best detention and accessorial charge software for manufacturers?
The best fit is software that checks each detention and accessorial line against the load's own records: the rate confirmation, the appointment, the arrival and departure times and the POD. Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, books and tracks the load, audits each of these lines, and holds the whole invoice for a person when one does not match.
What is detention and accessorial charge software?
It is software that checks the extra charges on a carrier invoice before payment. It compares each charge with the agreed terms and the proof that the event or service happened, and holds unsupported charges for a person.
How does software check a detention charge?
It ties the line to one stop, finds the free time and hourly rate in the terms, collects the appointment, arrival and departure times, and recalculates the charge. If the recalculated amount is lower, the difference goes back to the carrier with the records.
Does Wilson audit detention charges?
Yes. Wilson audits each detention line against the recorded times and the agreed terms, and sends unsupported charges back to the carrier with evidence. Where configured, it asks the warehouse or receiver for check-in and departure times.
Does Wilson pay the undisputed part of an invoice?
No. Wilson does not make partial payments. If any line does not match, the whole invoice waits for a person.
How common is truck driver detention?
ATRI reported that drivers were detained at 39.3% of stops in 2023. It estimated more than 135 million hours lost, $3.6 billion in direct costs and $11.5 billion in lost productivity for the industry.
Can software prevent accessorial charges, not just dispute them?
Partly. Many accessorials come from requirements nobody shared at booking, such as a liftgate or a delivery appointment. Capturing those requirements before the quote means the price includes them and the invoice holds fewer surprises.
Is freight audit software the same as detention software?
Not always. Freight audit software checks the whole invoice, often against rate tables. Detention checks need stop times, so ask any freight audit vendor where its arrival and departure times come from.
Should we dispute every detention charge?
No. If your dock or the receiver held the truck past free time, the carrier earned the charge. Dispute only the lines the records do not support.
Which records should we keep for each detention charge?
Keep the appointment, the actual arrival and departure times with their sources, the signed BOL or POD, and the detention terms from the rate confirmation. Keep any message about a changed appointment too.
Sources
- Cartage, Wilson product FAQ and product scope, October 2026: https://cartage.ai
- American Transportation Research Institute, "New Research Documents Substantial Financial and Safety Impacts from Truck Driver Detention," September 2024, accessed November 22, 2026: https://truckingresearch.org/2024/09/new-research-documents-substantial-financial-and-safety-impacts-from-truck-driver-detention/
- Loop, official website, accessed November 22, 2026: https://www.loop.com
- AFS Logistics, official website, accessed November 22, 2026: https://www.afs.net
- CT Logistics, official website, accessed November 22, 2026: https://www.ctlogistics.com
- Tranzact, official website, accessed November 22, 2026: https://www.tranzact.com
- Intelligent Audit, official website, accessed November 22, 2026: https://www.intelligentaudit.com
