We bid on contracts that include freight. How do we estimate freight fast enough to bid?
How do we estimate freight fast enough to bid?
A hypothetical manufacturer of commercial lighting fixtures receives a request for proposal on Monday. A regional retail chain wants delivered pricing for 12 months on fixtures shipped to 48 stores in nine states, with a monthly replenishment to two distribution centers. Answers are due Thursday at noon. The sales director needs one freight number per destination, or a freight percentage the chain will accept, by Wednesday afternoon so finance can approve the margin. The logistics coordinator has three other priorities that week and no time to request quotes for 50 destinations.
To estimate freight fast enough to bid, group the bid's destinations into lanes and shipment sizes, price each group from your recent quotes and booked loads, add named buffers for fuel, accessorials and market movement, request fresh quotes only for the groups where history is thin or the risk is high, and write the validity and fuel terms into the bid. The aim is a number the company can live with for the contract term, produced in the time the bid allows.
A freight estimate for a bid isn't a freight quote. A quote is a carrier's offer for a specific shipment on a specific date. A bid estimate is the company's own forecast of what a stream of future shipments will cost, which it then turns into a price for its customer. The two use the same inputs, but the estimate has to cover months of shipments the company hasn't booked yet.
Why bids get the freight wrong
Most bid freight errors fall into four patterns:
- Last year's average carried forward. The number was right for last year's lanes, not this customer's destinations.
- Base rate without accessorials. Retail stores often need liftgate, appointments or limited-access delivery. A dock-to-dock rate understates the cost.
- No allowance for fuel. Diesel moves over a year. A fixed freight price with no fuel clause shifts that risk entirely onto the seller.
- One number for everything. A single freight percentage across all destinations hides the expensive lanes inside the cheap ones, until the expensive lanes are where the volume goes.
Choose a method for each part of the bid
Not every destination needs the same effort. Match the method to the situation.
| Situation in the bid | Estimate method | Time needed |
|---|---|---|
| Destination in a region you ship to every week | Median of recent booked loads on the lane, adjusted to the bid's shipment size | Minutes per lane |
| Destination near a regular lane, same mode and size | Nearest regular lane, adjusted for distance and any new accessorials | Minutes per lane |
| Region you ship to occasionally | Recent quotes plus a wider buffer, or two or three fresh quotes | A few hours |
| Region you have never shipped to | Fresh quotes from approved carriers on a sample of destinations | A day or more |
| Heavy, recurring volume on one lane | Fresh quotes, ideally priced as contract freight rather than spot | A day or more |
| Special equipment, temperature control or firm delivery dates | Fresh quotes with the service written into the request | A day or more |
On a short deadline, the first two rows usually cover most of the destinations. The time saved there pays for fresh quotes where they matter.
Let's review the lanes in your next bid. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers.
Book a demo →How do you build lane estimates from recent quotes and shipment history?
Pull the last few months of booked loads and quotes, group them by lane, mode and shipment size, take a median per group and adjust it to the shipments the bid describes. The steps below fit in a spreadsheet and can be repeated for every bid.
Step 1: Describe the shipments the bid will create
Before touching history, turn the request for proposal into a shipment profile. For each destination or group of destinations, write down:
- expected shipments per month;
- typical size: pallets, weight, cube and freight class for LTL;
- likely mode: parcel, LTL, volume LTL or truckload;
- delivery requirements: liftgate, appointment, inside delivery, delivery windows, store hours;
- origin: which plant or warehouse will ship it.
If the request for proposal doesn't say, make an assumption and write it down. "Assumes two pallets per store per month, 900 pounds, dock delivery at DCs and liftgate at stores" is a usable starting point. Sales can confirm it with the customer before the bid goes out.
Step 2: Group destinations into lanes
Group destinations that will price similarly. A common approach is the origin plus the destination's three-digit ZIP prefix or metro area. For LTL, carriers price by origin, destination, class and weight, so keep the weight band in the group. For truckload, the origin and destination region and the equipment matter most.
In the hypothetical lighting bid, 48 stores collapse into 11 groups: four metro areas with several stores each, five smaller regional clusters and two outlying single stores. The two DCs are separate truckload lanes.
Step 3: Pull matching history
For each group, pull booked loads and quotes from the last 90 days on the same or nearby lanes, with the same mode and a similar size. Use booked rates and paid invoices where you have them, and keep quoted, booked and paid amounts in separate columns. A paid amount may include detention or a redelivery that shouldn't drive a bid price. The method in how to benchmark freight rates by lane from your own shipments covers how to group and compare these records.
Step 4: Take a median and a range
For each group, record the number of loads, the median all-in cost and the low and high. The median is less affected by one unusual shipment than the average. If a group has fewer than three comparable loads, mark it as thin history and plan fresh quotes for it.
Step 5: Adjust to the bid's shipment size
LTL cost doesn't scale in a straight line with weight. Rates per hundredweight drop at weight breaks, and minimum charges apply to small shipments. Convert history to cost per hundredweight within a weight band, then apply it to the bid's expected weight. For truckload, the trip cost is close to fixed, so the question is how many loads per month, not how many pounds.
Step 6: Add the accessorials the bid requires
If history was mostly dock deliveries and the bid's stores need liftgate and appointments, add those charges. Use your carriers' accessorial schedules, or the amounts on recent invoices for the same services. A guide to checking accessorial charges before booking lists the common ones.
A hypothetical worked example
| Group | Shipments per month | Size | History (loads, median) | Adjusted base | Accessorials | Estimate per shipment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metro A, 9 stores | 18 | 2 pallets, 900 lb | 22 loads, $318 | $310 | Liftgate $85, appointment $40 | $435 |
| Metro B, 7 stores | 14 | 2 pallets, 900 lb | 9 loads, $362 | $355 | Liftgate $85, appointment $40 | $480 |
| Regional cluster C, 4 stores | 8 | 2 pallets, 900 lb | 4 loads, $401 | $395 | Liftgate $85, appointment $40 | $520 |
| Outlying store D | 2 | 2 pallets, 900 lb | 1 load | Thin: fresh quotes | Liftgate, limited access | Pending quotes |
| DC 1, truckload | 3 | 24 pallets | 14 loads, $2,140 | $2,140 | None | $2,140 |
| DC 2, truckload | 2 | 24 pallets | 0 loads | Thin: fresh quotes | None | Pending quotes |
The numbers are illustrations of the method, not market rates. Three of the six rows are ready in an afternoon. Two need fresh quotes, and those requests can go out on Monday so answers arrive before Wednesday.
Turn estimates into a bid price
The bid may ask for a delivered price per unit, a freight line per order or a freight percentage. Each can come from the same table:
- Per order: the estimate per shipment, plus buffers.
- Per unit: the estimate per shipment divided by the expected units per shipment. The guide on calculating freight cost per unit shows the method and its traps.
- Percentage of sale: total estimated freight across the contract divided by total expected revenue, checked group by group so the expensive lanes aren't hidden.
How much buffer should a freight estimate carry?
Carry a separate, named buffer for each risk: fuel, accessorials not yet known, market movement over the contract term and volume that differs from the forecast. A single round-up of "plus 15%" is hard to defend and hard to adjust when one of the risks changes.
Four common buffers
| Buffer | What it protects against | How to size it |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Diesel price changes over the contract term | Use a fuel clause instead where the customer accepts one; otherwise look at the range of fuel surcharges you paid over the last year |
| Accessorials | Store or site requirements the request for proposal didn't mention | Look at how often similar deliveries picked up unplanned charges in your history |
| Market | General rate movement over the term, especially for truckload | Compare recent quotes with the same lanes a year ago; widen for longer terms |
| Volume | Fewer, smaller shipments than forecast, which raise cost per unit | Price the per-unit freight at a lower volume scenario and see how much it changes |
There is no standard size for any of these. The right buffer depends on the lanes, the term and how much of the risk the contract passes back to the customer. The point of naming them is that sales can trade one against another. If the customer accepts a fuel clause, the fuel buffer can come out of the price.
Fuel: clause or buffer
Fuel is the largest single swing in many freight budgets. Carriers usually price fuel as a surcharge tied to a published weekly diesel average, such as the U.S. Energy Information Administration's on-highway diesel price. A bid can handle fuel two ways:
- A fuel clause. The freight portion of the price adjusts when the diesel index moves beyond a set band. The customer shares the risk, and the seller can bid closer to the current cost.
- A fuel buffer. The price includes an allowance for higher fuel. The seller carries the risk, and the bid price is higher.
Many buyers expect a fuel clause on long contracts. If the customer won't accept one, size the fuel buffer from the range you actually paid, not from today's surcharge alone. The article on rising fuel prices and freight costs explains how surcharges follow diesel.
Accessorials that hide in contract requirements
Requests for proposal often bury delivery rules deep in the document: delivery windows, appointment requirements, inside delivery, pallet height limits, labeling and compliance chargebacks. Read for them before estimating. Every one either adds a carrier charge or a risk of a customer penalty. If the contract imposes chargebacks for late or non-compliant deliveries, price the service that avoids them, not the cheapest service. The guide on avoiding retailer chargebacks for late shipments covers the common ones.
Volume risk
Freight cost per unit rises when shipments are smaller than planned. If the bid assumes two pallets per store per month and the stores order one pallet twice a month, the shipment count doubles and the cost per unit rises, especially near LTL minimum charges. Run the estimate at the forecast volume and at a lower volume, and see how far the per-unit cost moves. If the gap is large, consider a minimum order quantity or a freight charge for small orders in the bid.
How long is a freight estimate valid, and what should the bid say?
A freight estimate is valid only as long as its assumptions hold, so the bid should state the period, the assumptions and how freight adjusts if they change. Clear terms protect the margin more than any buffer.
Validity of the underlying quotes
Carrier spot quotes are often valid for a short period, sometimes only for a specific pickup date. Contract rates usually run for a set term, such as a year, but can include fuel and accessorial changes. If the estimate rests on spot quotes, it reflects today's market, not next spring's. Note the date of every quote used and its stated validity. The difference between the two kinds of price is covered in spot quotes versus contract rates.
Terms worth writing into the bid
| Term | Example wording to adapt | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Price validity | "Freight pricing valid for 90 days from submission." | Protects against a late award at old prices |
| Fuel adjustment | "Freight adjusts with the weekly national diesel average beyond a stated band." | Shares fuel risk over the contract term |
| Assumed shipment profile | "Based on two pallets, 900 lb, per store order." | Gives grounds to reprice if orders are smaller |
| Accessorials included | "Includes liftgate and appointment at stores; inside delivery billed separately." | Stops disputes about services not priced |
| Freight terms | "Delivered, freight prepaid by seller." | Makes clear who pays the carrier and who carries the freight risk |
| Review point | "Freight reviewed at six months against actual cost." | Allows a correction before a full year of losses |
These are hypothetical examples, not legal wording. The company's commercial and legal teams decide the final terms. The article on prepaid, collect and third-party freight terms explains how those terms change who pays and who files claims.
Who owns the numbers after the award
A bid estimate becomes a commitment once the contract is signed. Agree who tracks actual freight cost against the estimate, by lane group, from the first month. If actual cost runs above the estimate on a group, the team needs to know in month two, not at the six-month review. The guide on building next year's freight budget uses the same monthly tracking approach.
When do you need fresh quotes instead of history?
Request fresh quotes when the history is thin, the lane is new, the volume is large enough to deserve contract pricing, or the service is unusual. History is fast but it can only tell you about lanes and services you have already shipped.
Signals that history is not enough
- Fewer than three comparable loads on the lane in the last few months.
- A new region where the company has no carrier experience.
- A different mode from what history covers, such as truckload history for a bid that will ship LTL.
- Recurring heavy volume on one lane, where contract rates may beat spot pricing.
- Special handling: temperature control, flatbed, hazmat or high-value freight.
- Firm delivery commitments with penalties, where the carrier's on-time record matters as much as the price.
- A long contract term in a market that has moved recently.
How to request quotes for a bid
Carriers price better when the request describes the freight stream, not a single load. Include:
- The lanes, with origin and destination ZIP codes.
- Expected shipments per week or month and typical size.
- Mode, equipment, freight class for LTL and handling notes.
- Delivery requirements: appointments, liftgate, windows.
- The term and start date.
- Whether the price should include fuel or show it separately.
- The deadline for responses.
Use the same request format for every carrier so the answers can be compared. The freight quote checklist lists the fields carriers need. If the company later runs a formal carrier bid for the awarded volume, the process in running a freight bid for your lanes applies; that is a different exercise from estimating freight for your own customer's bid.
Sample, don't survey
For a bid with many destinations, quote a sample in each group rather than every address. In the hypothetical lighting bid, two quotes for the outlying store and three for the new DC lane are enough to close the gaps. The rest comes from history.
A two-day timeline
| Day | Bid team | Logistics |
|---|---|---|
| Day 1 morning | Shares the destinations, volumes and delivery rules | Groups destinations and pulls history |
| Day 1 afternoon | Confirms shipment profile assumptions with the customer | Prices groups with good history; sends quote requests for thin groups |
| Day 2 morning | Reviews the draft freight table | Adds buffers and accessorials; follows up on open quote requests |
| Day 2 afternoon | Decides fuel terms, validity and review point | Fills in fresh quotes and hands over the final table with assumptions |
A bid due in three days can follow this pattern with a day to spare. Shorter deadlines skip the fresh quotes and widen the buffers on thin groups instead, with that choice written down.
How does Wilson, by Cartage, help a team price freight for a bid?
Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that requests quotes from the company's approved carriers and its network, compares them on total cost and keeps every quote and booked load on record, and it can produce lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs, which is the raw material of a bid estimate. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward.
Wilson works as a free logistics department for manufacturers and distributors: what big shippers build over years, Wilson does from day one. Each of its four parts matters to a bid, before and after the award.
The labor
The labor is the quote work a bid deadline doesn't leave time for. When the bid team needs fresh prices on thin lanes, Wilson sends the same request to approved carriers in one format, follows up with carriers that haven't replied and compares the answers on total cost, including the accessorials the bid requires. After the award, it does the shipment work start to finish, from the first quote to the final POD: bookings, paperwork, tracking and carrier follow-ups, by email, phone calls, texts, Slack and Teams. The team doesn't chase carriers.
The data
The data is where the history comes from. Wilson keeps every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact on record as it works, connected to the company's ERP. Records are searchable and exportable with change history, so the bid team can start from real booked loads instead of a coordinator's memory. Wilson can produce lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs. It does not run recurring benchmarking or keep a permanent scorecard by default. Rules the team adds, such as a hypothetical note that a retail customer's stores accept deliveries only before 10 am, stay on record and shape later quotes, and the team can edit them. Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope.
The network
The network widens the set of prices a bid can use. The shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's, which can bring better freight rates on its lanes, and the network includes carriers and brokers. Only volume is combined: two customers shipping the same lane share no data. That helps most on lanes where the company has little history. The company still approves who hauls its freight, and it can keep its own carriers on any lane.
The payments
The payments show whether the bid estimate holds after the award. Wilson audits every freight invoice against the load before money moves, then pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. Invoices over the rate or outside the rules wait for a person, and Wilson asks the carrier why an invoice is over the rate before paying it. Because each paid amount sits on the load, actual cost by lane can be compared with the bid estimate month by month.
What Wilson does and what the team decides
| Bid step | What Wilson does | What the team decides |
|---|---|---|
| History for the lanes | Produces a lane-rate report on request from the loads it runs | Which lanes and periods to include |
| Fresh quotes for thin lanes | Requests and compares quotes from approved carriers and the network | Which carriers are approved |
| Buffers and margin | Supplies the quotes and history behind them | Buffer sizes, margin and the final price |
| Bid terms | None | Fuel clause, validity, review point |
| Shipping after the award | Quotes, books from the company's ranked carrier list for each lane, tracks, audits and pays within approval limits | Carrier ranking, approval limits and exceptions |
Wilson starts with assisted execution. The company sets approval limits, and routine actions can run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven. It handles LTL, FTL, ocean, drayage, parcel and cross-border freight. It is not a freight broker or a customs broker. How fast a lane-rate report can be ready for a specific bid depends on the setup and the history on record; confirm it in discovery.
Pricing
Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.
FAQs
Can Wilson price freight for a bid?
Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, can request quotes from the company's approved carriers and its network for the bid's lanes and can produce lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs. The company's team sets the buffers, margin and bid terms. How the work fits a specific bid deadline depends on the setup; confirm it in discovery.
How do you estimate freight cost for a contract bid?
Turn the bid into a shipment profile, group destinations into lanes and weight bands, take the median all-in cost from recent loads on each group, add the accessorials the contract requires and named buffers for fuel, market and volume, and request fresh quotes where history is thin.
How much should we add to freight in a bid?
There is no standard percentage. Size each buffer separately: fuel, unknown accessorials, market movement and volume. If the customer accepts a fuel clause, the fuel buffer can be smaller or removed.
Should a bid include a fuel surcharge clause?
On contracts longer than a few months, a fuel clause tied to a published diesel index is common and lets the seller bid closer to current cost. Without one, the seller carries the fuel risk and should price it.
How long is a freight quote valid?
It depends on the carrier and the type of price. Spot quotes are often valid for a short period or a specific pickup date. Contract rates usually run for a set term. Note the date and validity of every quote used in an estimate.
Can we use one freight percentage for every destination?
You can, but check it group by group first. A single percentage can hide expensive lanes, and if volume shifts toward them, the margin goes with it.
What if the contract's orders are smaller than we assumed?
Smaller orders raise freight cost per unit, especially near LTL minimum charges. Write the assumed shipment profile into the bid so there are grounds to reprice, or set a minimum order or small-order freight charge.
Should we get fresh quotes for every destination in a bid?
Usually not. Price destinations with good history from recent loads and request fresh quotes for a sample in each thin group: new regions, new modes, heavy recurring lanes and special equipment.
Sources
- U.S. Energy Information Administration, Gasoline and Diesel Fuel Update: https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/gasdiesel/
- Cartage, Wilson product FAQ and product scope, October 2026: https://cartage.ai
Let's review the lanes in your next bid. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.
