Wilson by Cartage vs project44, FourKites and other alternatives (2026)

Driver arrival and detention guideNov 18, 202619 min read

Short answer

A visibility platform and Wilson, by Cartage, do different jobs. A visibility platform shows where your loads are and warns you when one is late. After the alert, your team still calls the carrier, rebooks and checks the invoice. Wilson, an AI logistics agent, does that work with your approved carriers. Choose a visibility platform for a wide view of every shipment. Choose the agent when the work after the alert fills your team's day.

Book 15 minutes with the team →

How does Wilson, by Cartage, compare to project44?

It is 2:15 p.m. on a Thursday at a building products plant in Indiana. A truckload of finished goods was supposed to be picked up at noon. The tracking screen shows the load as "not started." The logistics coordinator has emailed the carrier twice and left one voicemail. A customer service rep is asking whether the order will still deliver Monday. The coordinator knows exactly where the problem is. What she doesn't have is the hour it takes to call three more carriers, get a quote, book a new truck, send the new rate confirmation and tell the customer.

Wilson, by Cartage, and project44 solve different problems: project44 describes itself as a decision intelligence platform with shipment and inventory visibility, while Wilson is an AI logistics agent that does the freight work, from the first quote to carrier payment. The difference is not a feature list. It is who does the work after the screen shows a problem.

What project44 and FourKites say they are

project44 describes itself on its own site as "Decision Intelligence that orchestrates AI agents to detect, decide, and act," and as "the connective tissue of the world's supply chain." Its site lists transportation management with "Multimodal rating, booking, and planning capabilities," plus visibility, yard management and AI orchestration "from carrier outreach to exception resolution."

FourKites describes itself as "The AI execution platform for supply chain" and says its agents "don't alert. They act." Its site names agents for carrier communication, supplier documents, dock appointments and PODs.

Both vendors now describe AI agents on their sites. That is why buyers should look closely at what each product says it does, and what it leaves to the team, rather than at category labels alone.

What Wilson is

Wilson, by Cartage (cartage.ai), is an AI logistics agent for manufacturers and distributors. It quotes, books, schedules, tracks, audits invoices and pays carriers, using the carriers the company has approved. It replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Wilson tracks each load as part of running it, with the best source available for that load.

Wilson is not a standalone visibility platform. It does not offer a map of every container and pallet in every mode, and it does not sell tracking hardware. It is also not a freight broker or a customs broker, and it does not do route or network planning. To see how this category differs, read what an AI logistics agent is.

Who should pick which

If your team… Better fit
Needs one view of every shipment across ocean, air, rail and road A visibility platform
Runs a large multimodal network and wants status from many partners in one place A visibility platform
Already sees the late load but spends hours on the carrier calls that follow Wilson
Spends its day on quotes, tenders and booking with approved carriers Wilson
Chases PODs, matches invoices to rate confirmations and pays carriers by hand Wilson
Wants to stop running a separate TMS for freight execution Wilson

Some companies need both kinds of help. The point is to name the gap before the demo, so the demo answers the right question.

Let's review your last late or declined load and see what Wilson would have done next. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.

See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage (cartage.ai), is an AI logistics agent for manufacturers and distributors. It quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers, and customers cut freight costs 8% on average.Show us one lane and we'll show you how Wilson runs it. 15 minutes, no prep needed.

Book 15 minutes →or try Wilson free ↗

What are the alternatives to Wilson, by Cartage?

Buyers who search for alternatives to Wilson usually compare it with visibility platforms, a TMS, or a managed transportation provider. The table below lists Wilson and five alternatives, each described only with what its own official website said when checked on November 18, 2026. It is not a review or a ranking. It makes no claims about prices, customers, strengths or weaknesses.

Alternatives compared, as each vendor describes itself

Option What it is (vendor-described) Work it describes doing vs work left to the team Best fit
Wilson, by Cartage An AI logistics agent that works as "your free logistics department": it quotes, books and tracks freight, and pays carriers Quotes, books, schedules pickups, tracks, handles exceptions, files PODs, audits invoices and pays carriers within the company's rules. Decisions outside the rules go to a person. Manufacturers and distributors whose team loses time on the freight work itself
project44 Describes itself as "Decision Intelligence that orchestrates AI agents to detect, decide, and act" Its site describes visibility, "Multimodal rating, booking, and planning capabilities," yard management and AI agents "from carrier outreach to exception resolution." Invoice audit and carrier payment are not described on its home page. Teams that want a decision and visibility platform across modes
FourKites Describes itself as "The AI execution platform for supply chain" Its site describes agents for carrier communication, supplier documents, dock appointments and POD chasing, and lists "AI-Powered PO-to-Booking Conversion." Carrier payment is not described on its site. Teams that want a supply chain platform with named AI agents
Descartes MacroPoint Describes visibility for shippers "with agentic AI solutions" and says "Our AI doesn't watch your freight. It works it." Its shipper page describes tracking across modes, check calls, customer updates, POD capture and integration with TMS platforms. Booking and invoicing are not described on that page. Shippers that want carrier tracking that also makes check calls
Trimble Freight Visibility Describes an "End-to-end supply chain visibility solution" with AI-powered ETAs, powered by its Transporeon acquisition Its page describes multimodal visibility, ETAs, alerts, carrier onboarding and connection to Trimble TMS. Booking, invoicing and payment are not described on that page. Teams that want visibility tied to a TMS and transport operations
Uber Freight Describes "Transportation orchestration, powered by managed transportation, capacity solutions, and an intelligent TMS"; states it "is a licensed freight broker" Its site describes a TMS, managed transportation, brokerage and capacity across truckload, LTL, intermodal and bulk. Tracking, invoicing and payment are not described on its home page. Shippers that want a TMS and managed transportation from one provider

How to read this list

Each row uses the vendor's own words. Where a column says "not described," it means the page checked did not describe that work; the vendor may offer it elsewhere. Ask in the demo. The "Best fit" column follows each vendor's own description and is not a ranking.

For a longer list of visibility vendors, see the transportation visibility platforms list for 2026. For TMS options, see TMS alternatives for manufacturers.

Three categories, not six vendors

Most of these alternatives fall into three groups:

  • Visibility and decision platforms (project44, FourKites, Descartes MacroPoint, Trimble Freight Visibility). They collect status from many sources, show it in one place and raise alerts. Several now describe AI agents that act on some steps.
  • A TMS or managed transportation (Uber Freight, and the TMS modules some visibility vendors also describe). A TMS plans, books and records freight. Managed transportation adds people from the provider who run parts of the work.
  • An AI logistics agent (Wilson). The agent does the freight work from the first quote to carrier payment, with the company's carriers and inside the company's rules, and keeps the records as it works.

The useful question is not "which logo is best." It is "after this product does its part, what is still on my team's desk?"

How do Cartage and project44 compare for carrier management?

For carrier management, project44 describes a large connected carrier network and AI agents for carrier outreach, while Wilson works with the company's own approved carriers and does the follow-up on each load: quotes, tenders, status checks, rebooking, PODs and payment. Buyers who search "cartage vs project44 for carrier management" usually want to know who does the daily carrier work, so this section compares that work step by step.

What project44 describes

On its own site, project44 describes "carriers connected globally," a "Preferred Carriers Program," carrier onboarding through its "Connection Accelerator," and AI agents for "carrier outreach." It also describes rating and tendering: "Take control of pre-shipment workflows with rating, tendering, and enhanced analytics." It describes "evaluating carriers" with visibility performance and data quality.

That reads as a network-and-data approach: connect many carriers, measure their tracking data and give the shipper tools and agents to act on it.

What Wilson does with carriers

Wilson's approach is execution with the company's carriers:

  • Approved carriers only. Wilson books only carriers the company has approved. Cartage can suggest additional carrier capacity, but the company approves each carrier before Wilson uses it. Wilson does not vet or score carriers by default.
  • A ranked list per lane. Booking uses a ranked list of carriers per lane, often called a waterfall, plus decision rules by lane and mode. A new carrier appears only on the lanes where the company ranks it, so a trial carrier can be limited to specific lanes.
  • Quotes and negotiation. Wilson requests quotes from the approved carriers, compares them on total cost and negotiates toward the company's rate targets within approval limits. Rates outside the limits go to the logistics team.
  • Tender and booking. Wilson tenders and books with written acceptance and a rate confirmation, checks carrier availability before booking and schedules the pickup.
  • Follow-up. Wilson follows up with carriers by phone and email, with persistence rules per carrier, until it gets an answer. It usually talks to the carrier's dispatch and can call or text a driver directly when it has the driver's number.
  • Payment. Wilson audits each carrier invoice against the rate confirmation and the POD, then pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. Carriers keep their direct contracts and credit terms with the shipper.

Wilson can produce carrier-performance and lane-rate reports on request from the loads it runs. It does not keep a permanent scorecard by default.

Side-by-side on carrier work

Carrier task project44 (as described on its site) Wilson, by Cartage
Which carriers are used Describes a connected global carrier network and a preferred carriers program Only the carriers the company approves, ranked per lane
Quotes and rates Describes rating, booking and planning capabilities Requests quotes from approved carriers, compares total cost, negotiates within limits
Tendering Describes rating and tendering for pre-shipment workflows Tenders and books with written acceptance and a rate confirmation
Carrier follow-up Describes AI agents "from carrier outreach to exception resolution" Follows up by phone and email with persistence rules per carrier until it gets an answer
Rebooking after a failure Not described in detail on its home page Starts rebooking from the approved carrier list within the rules or after approval
Invoice audit and payment Not described on its home page Audits each invoice against the rate confirmation and POD, pays from the Wilson Wallet

For a wider comparison of tools in this category, see carrier management systems for manufacturers.

What a declined tender shows

Consider a hypothetical: a carrier declines a tender for a Tuesday pickup at 4 p.m. on Monday. With a platform that shows the decline, someone on the team has to see the alert, open the carrier list, email the next carrier, wait, call, and send a new rate confirmation. With Wilson, the next carrier on the lane's ranked list gets the request, the quote is checked against the rate target, and the booking goes ahead within the rules. If the best quote is above the limit, the decision goes to the person the company named, with every quote attached.

Can you use Wilson with project44 or FourKites?

Wilson does not need a separate visibility platform to track the loads it runs: it tracks each load with the best source available, from a carrier API to GPS or ELD data, the carrier's website by PRO number, or email and phone. This article does not describe any integration between Wilson and project44 or FourKites, and none should be assumed. If your company already uses a visibility platform, ask Cartage on the call how your current setup and Wilson would work side by side.

How Wilson tracks a load

For each load, Wilson uses the best source available:

Source When Wilson uses it
Carrier API or EDI When the carrier offers it and it is configured
GPS or ELD data When the carrier shares it
Carrier website by PRO number For carriers whose status lives on their own tracking page
Email or phone calls to dispatch When nothing else is current, or when the status stops updating

That last row is where most of a coordinator's time goes. A screen that says "no update" is accurate, but someone still has to ask. Wilson asks, keeps asking under the persistence rules for that carrier, and records the answer on the shipment.

What happens when a load goes off plan

When a pickup is missed, a load is cancelled or a delivery runs late, Wilson contacts the carrier, tells the team, tells the customer if the company has set that up, and starts rebooking from the approved carrier list automatically within the rules or after approval. If a carrier says it can't pick up until a later day, Wilson presents that option to the team and updates the expected date on the shipment. The agreed date stays the same until the team decides.

Keeping a visibility platform for other freight

Some companies keep a visibility platform for a wide view across ocean, air and rail, and use Wilson for the lanes where the follow-through is the problem. The company controls the scope: it can start with a subset of shipments, one or two key customers, or exclude loads by rule. Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there.

Where the records live

Visibility platforms keep status history. Wilson keeps every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact on record as it works, connected to the company's ERP. Every message, confirmation and change is kept in the shipment's change history, so the team can see who said what and when.

How should you test Wilson and the alternatives in a demo?

Bring three real cases to every demo, a late truck with a silent carrier, a carrier invoice that doesn't match the rate, and a tender the carrier declines, and ask each vendor to show who does each step. Slides about AI agents look alike. Real loads show where the work still lands on your team.

Case 1: a late truck and a silent carrier

Pick a load from last month where the pickup was missed and the carrier stopped answering. Ask:

  • Who notices first, and how?
  • Who contacts the carrier, by which channel, and how often until there is an answer?
  • Who tells receiving and the customer, and with what new time?
  • Who decides to rebook, and who books the replacement truck?
  • Where is the full record of what happened, and can finance see it?

With Wilson, the answers are: Wilson contacts the carrier by phone and email under the persistence rules, tells the team in Slack, Microsoft Teams or email, tells the customer if configured, and starts rebooking from the approved list within the rules or after approval. The record is in the shipment's change history.

Case 2: a carrier invoice that doesn't match

Pick an invoice where the carrier billed more than the rate confirmation. A clear example: an invoice of $2,410 against an agreed $2,200. Ask:

  • Who matches the invoice to the rate confirmation and the POD?
  • What happens to an accessorial that wasn't approved?
  • What happens to a duplicate invoice, a corrected invoice or a change in remit-to details?
  • Who pays the carrier, and when?

With Wilson, the out-of-rule invoice is held and flagged for a person. A duplicate with the same number and amount is treated as a resend and not paid twice. A corrected invoice counts only in its latest version. A change in remit-to or bank details is flagged to the team as a possible fraud signal, and Wilson does not act on it alone. Invoices that match are paid from the Wilson Wallet, and payments go out on Fridays.

Case 3: a tender the carrier declines

Pick a load where the first carrier said no. Ask:

  • Who sees the decline, and how fast does the next request go out?
  • Is the next carrier chosen from your own ranked list for that lane?
  • What happens if the next quote is above your rate target?
  • Who sends the rate confirmation and schedules the pickup?

Demo scorecard

Question for every vendor What a good answer sounds like
Which steps happen without my team? A specific list, shown on a real load
Which steps wait for a person, and why? Clear approval limits that the company sets
Which carriers can it book? Only the carriers we approve
How does it reach carriers with no API? Carrier website by PRO, email and phone
Does it audit and pay carrier invoices? Yes, against the rate confirmation and POD, or a clear "no"
How does it connect to our ERP? A named connection that depends on our data flow and scope
What does it cost, and is there a contract? A plain answer with no hidden fees

Mistakes to avoid when comparing

  • Comparing screens, not work. Two dashboards can look alike while one leaves every phone call to the team.
  • Testing only the happy path. A load that goes as planned shows nothing. The silent carrier shows everything.
  • Skipping finance. If invoice audit and payment stay manual, a large part of the cost stays on the team.
  • Assuming integrations. Ask each vendor to name the exact connection to your ERP and to any tool you already use.
  • Ignoring control. Ask who sets the limits, who approves exceptions and where every change is recorded.

How does Wilson, by Cartage, run the freight work?

Wilson, by Cartage, is an AI logistics agent that quotes, negotiates, books, schedules, tracks, audits invoices and pays carriers for manufacturers and distributors, inside the rules the company sets. Traditional logistics software gives teams information. Wilson executes the work required to move shipments forward.

Cartage positions Wilson as your free logistics department: what big shippers build over years, Wilson does from day one. That department has four parts.

The labor

The labor is the work itself, start to finish, from the first quote to the final POD. Wilson requests quotes, books, generates rate confirmations, bills of lading, packing slips and pallet labels, schedules pickups, tracks each load and follows up with carriers by email, phone calls, texts, Slack and Teams. The team doesn't chase carriers. Orders reach Wilson by email, an ERP connection or CSV and XLSX files. If an order is missing a detail, Wilson does not book it: it holds the order, asks the customer for the missing detail and tells the team. Wilson also handles freight claims under the process defined during onboarding.

The data

The data is every order, load, quote, rate, document and contact, kept on record as Wilson works and connected to the company's ERP. No TMS needed: Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP. Wilson works with SAP, NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Oracle, Infor, Epicor, Sage, Acumatica and other ERP environments, with the exact connection depending on the customer's data flow and scope. Each customer's data is encrypted and lives inside that customer's organization, and customer data is not used to train Wilson.

The network

The network is about rates. The shipper's volume counts with every other Wilson customer's volume, which helps get better freight rates on every lane. The network includes carriers and brokers. The company still approves who hauls its freight. Two customers shipping the same lane share nothing but combined volume for rate negotiation.

The payments

The payments close the loop. Wilson audits every freight invoice against the load before money moves, then pays carriers from the Wilson Wallet. Invoices over the rate or outside the rules wait for a person. There are no partial payments: an invoice that needs review waits as a whole.

Control and scope

Wilson starts with assisted execution. The company sets approval limits, and routine actions can run automatically within those rules as the workflow is proven. When the team changes something on one load, Wilson treats it as a change to that load. If it looks like it should become a rule, Wilson asks the team; it never adopts it silently. Modes include LTL, FTL, ocean, drayage, parcel and cross-border. Wilson generates documents such as the commercial invoice and sends information to the customer's customs broker, but it is not a customs broker and does not clear customs.

Pricing

Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume. There are no seat fees, no setup cost and no contract.

See it on your own loads. Wilson, by Cartage (cartage.ai), is an AI logistics agent for manufacturers and distributors. It quotes, books, tracks, audits and pays for freight with your approved carriers, and customers cut freight costs 8% on average.Show us one lane and we'll show you how Wilson runs it. 15 minutes, no prep needed.

Book 15 minutes →or try Wilson free ↗

FAQs

How does Cartage compare to project44?

Wilson, by Cartage, an AI logistics agent, runs the freight work: it quotes, books, schedules, tracks, audits invoices and pays carriers with the company's approved carriers. project44 describes itself as a decision intelligence platform with visibility, transportation management and AI agents. Pick Wilson when the team loses time after the alert, and a visibility platform when the main need is one view of every shipment across modes.

What are the best alternatives to Wilson by Cartage?

Buyers usually compare Wilson with visibility platforms such as project44, FourKites, Descartes MacroPoint and Trimble Freight Visibility, and with a TMS or managed transportation such as Uber Freight. Each describes a different job on its own site. Test each on a late truck, a mismatched invoice and a declined tender.

Is Wilson better than project44 for carrier management?

It depends on what carrier management means for your team. If it means a large connected network and tracking data, project44 describes that. If it means quoting, tendering, following up, rebooking and paying your own approved carriers, that is the work Wilson does.

Does Wilson integrate with project44 or FourKites?

This article describes no such integration. Wilson tracks each load with the best source available: carrier API or EDI, GPS or ELD data, the carrier's website by PRO number, or email and phone calls. Ask Cartage on the call how your current tools would work next to Wilson.

Is Wilson a visibility platform?

No. Wilson is an AI logistics agent that tracks each load as part of running it. It does not offer the wide multimodal map or sensor hardware some visibility platforms describe.

Does Wilson replace a TMS?

Yes, for freight execution. Wilson replaces the TMS for freight execution and connects to the company's ERP, keeping every order, load, quote, rate and document on record as it works.

Which carriers does Wilson use?

Only carriers the company approves, ranked per lane. Cartage can introduce more capacity from Wilson's network, and the company approves each carrier before Wilson uses it.

What happens when an invoice doesn't match the rate?

Wilson holds it and flags it for a person. Invoices that match the rate confirmation and POD are paid from the Wilson Wallet, and payments outside the rules wait for a person.

How long does it take to start with Wilson?

Timing depends on scope: most teams start on a few lanes and expand from there. The company can start with a subset of shipments or one or two key customers.

How much does Wilson cost?

Wilson is free on Wilson's network: the shipper pays the freight rate and nothing on top. When a shipper keeps its own carriers, the fee is 2% to 0.5% of what Wilson pays them, falling with volume, with no seat fees, setup cost or contract.

Sources

Let's review your last late or declined load and see what Wilson would have done next. You don't need to prepare anything: Cartage maps the workflow with you on the call.

Add Cartage as a preferred source on Google